Old TestamentIsaiah 58:3Major Prophets

“Have we fasted, say they, and thou seest not?”

The full verse · Isaiah 58:3 · KJV

Wherefore have we , say they, and thou not? wherefore have we our , and thou takest no ? Behold, in the of your ye , and all your .

Asked by

Israel

Spoken by God through Isaiah, quoting the people, "Wherefore have we fasted, say they" (Isaiah 58:3)

Asked to

God

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Israel’s double question expresses their indignation that God has ignored their fasting and self-affliction. By framing their grievance as questions rather than accusations, they imply God owes them recognition for their religious efforts and has failed to honor the implicit covenant bargain they assumed their rituals guaranteed.

The Response

What Scripture records

God responds directly through Isaiah, exposing the hypocrisy of their fasting. He declares that on their fast days they pursue their own pleasure, oppress their workers, and engage in quarreling and violence. Their fasts serve selfish interests rather than true humility, which explains why He takes no notice of their religious performances.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Israel’s questions drip with wounded pride and misplaced confidence in religious performance. The double interrogative structure, ‘Why have we fasted… Why have we humbled ourselves’, intensifies their complaint, suggesting God has ignored not one but multiple acts of devotion. The Hebrew tsום (fasted) and anah (afflicted/humbled) represent Israel’s most serious expressions of piety, yet God remains unmoved. The people chose questions rather than statements because direct accusation would expose their hearts too plainly; questions allow them to express entitlement while maintaining a veneer of pious confusion. This exchange reveals a devastating disconnect: Israel believed external compliance with religious forms automatically secured divine favor, treating covenant relationship as a transaction rather than transformation. God’s silence toward their fasting carries profound theological weight, ritual divorced from righteousness is not merely ineffective but offensive to the Holy One who demands justice, mercy, and humble walking with Him.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning