Old TestamentIsaiah 57:11Major Prophets

“Of whom hast thou been afraid or feared, that thou hast lied, and hast not remembered me, nor laid it to thy heart?”

The full verse · Isaiah 57:11 · KJV

And of whom hast thou been or , that thou hast , and hast not me, nor it to thy ? have not I held my even of , and thou me not?

Asked by

God

Speaking through Isaiah

Asked to

Israel

The nation pictured as an unfaithful wife, "thou hast discovered thyself to another than me" (Isaiah 57:8)

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

God forces Israel to confront the perverse logic of their irreverence. His silence, meant to invite repentance, has instead emboldened their sin. By asking rather than declaring, He makes them acknowledge that His forbearance has been misread as impotence, and that their fearlessness toward Him is both ungrateful and suicidal.

The Response

What Scripture records

The text provides no recorded answer, as the question is prophetic indictment not inviting dialogue. The historical record shows Judah’s continued impenitence through the Babylonian exile, demonstrating that God’s silence indeed failed to produce the fear it should have cultivated.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

God’s second question pivots from exposing Israel’s misplaced fear to examining their lack of proper fear. The rhetorical question expects affirmation, yes, God has been silent long, but uses that agreement to indict their response. Instead of interpreting His silence as patience inviting repentance, Israel read it as divine indifference permitting continued rebellion. The interrogative structure creates devastating irony: the very forbearance meant to woo them has emboldened their apostasy. God’s question forces them to connect two facts they’ve kept separate, His long silence and their fearlessness, and to see the causal perversity: they don’t fear Him because He’s been patient. This prepares for imminent judgment by removing their excuse. His patience has run its course not because He’s changed but because they’ve exhausted it.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning