Old TestamentIsaiah 45:10Major Prophets

“What begettest thou?”

The full verse · Isaiah 45:10 · KJV

unto him that unto his , What thou? or to the , What hast thou brought ?

Asked by

Israel

Spoken by God through Isaiah, about "him that saith unto his father" (Isaiah 45:10)

Asked to

God

Pictured as the father and mother questioned by the complainer (Isaiah 45:10)

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The question is rhetorical and rebuking, meant to confront Israel’s pride and rebellion in questioning God’s purposes. It challenges Israel to recognize God’s sovereignty as Creator and sustainer, warning against their presumption and disrespect (Isaiah 45:9-11). The intent is to restore reverence and obedience within the covenant relationship.

The Response

What Scripture records

God Himself rebukes Israel for questioning His sovereignty and creative authority (Isaiah 45:10). The response emphasizes that to question the Creator about His creation is futile and disrespectful. This highlights God’s ultimate authority over life and existence (Isaiah 45:9-11).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The double woe of Isaiah 45:9–10 frames a sharp boundary around the creature’s right to interrogate the Creator. The first woe addresses the pot questioning the potter; the second, presented as a question, addresses the child questioning the parent about the mystery of birth itself. The Hebrew מַה־תּוֹלִיד (mah-tolid, what are you begetting?) targets the act of generation, what lies entirely within the divine prerogative and is constitutive of the creature’s very existence. The question’s force depends on recognizing that the one asking ‘why were you made this way?’ has no standpoint outside of what was made by which to evaluate the making. Isaiah uses this to address Cyrus’s unexpected commission: Israel should not question why God uses a pagan king, any more than a child can question the mystery of their own birth. The parent does not owe the child an account of generation.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning