Old TestamentEzra 5:9Historical Books

“Who commanded you to build this house, and to make up these walls?”

The full verse · Ezra 5:9 · KJV

we , and unto them , you to , and to make ?

Asked by

Tattenai, His Associates

Tattenai and His Associates: quoting their own question in their letter "unto Darius the king" (Ezra 5:6)

Asked to

Elders

The Jewish builders, "the elders of the Jews" (Ezra 5:5)

The Scene

In their letter to Darius, Tatnai and his companions report what they saw at "the house of the great God" in Judea, where "this work goeth fast on, and prospereth in their hands" (Ezra 5:6-8).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

This is the same question Tatnai asked in Ezra 5:3, now reported to the king. The officials were telling Darius what they had done: they had asked the elders by whose authority they built, and asked their leaders' names (Ezra 5:9-10). Gill simply refers back to Ezra 5:3 for the question.

The officials' purpose in the letter was to let the king decide. They end by asking for "search ... in the king's treasure house" to see "whether it be so, that a decree was made of Cyrus the king" (Ezra 5:17). Matthew Henry sees their report as fair: they "told him truly what was done," not claiming, as the earlier letter did, that the Jews were fortifying the city. Gill agrees that they "fairly and fully related" the Jews' account in the letter.

The Response

What Scripture records

The letter itself records the elders' answer. "We are the servants of the God of heaven and earth, and build the house that was builded these many years ago, which a great king of Israel builded and set up" (Ezra 5:11). They explained that "our fathers had provoked the God of heaven unto wrath," so God gave them to Nebuchadnezzar, "who destroyed this house" (Ezra 5:12). Then "in the first year of Cyrus ... king Cyrus made a decree to build this house of God" (Ezra 5:13). Cyrus returned the temple vessels to Sheshbazzar, who "laid the foundation," and "since that time even until now hath it been in building, and yet it is not finished" (Ezra 5:14-16).

Darius had the records searched, and the decree was found (Ezra 6:1-3). He told the officials, "Let the work of this house of God alone" (Ezra 6:7), and even ordered the costs paid from the king's tribute (Ezra 6:8).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Ezra places two letters to Persian kings side by side. The first called Jerusalem "the rebellious and the bad city" and claimed the Jews had "set up the walls" (Ezra 4:12). The second simply reported what the officials saw and what the elders said, and left the king to check the records (Ezra 5:8-17). Matthew Henry comments, "Let but the cause of God and truth be fairly stated, and fairly heard, and it will keep its ground."

The elders' answer also shows how they understood their own story. They did not hide Israel's failure. They said God had given them over "after that our fathers had provoked the God of heaven unto wrath" (Ezra 5:12). But the same God had opened the way back through Cyrus's decree (Ezra 5:13). Their confidence did not rest on their own record but on being "the servants of the God of heaven and earth" (Ezra 5:11), and on what He had set in motion.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, the elders could name both their fathers' sin and Your mercy in the same answer; how can I speak honestly about my story so that it points to You?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The elders admitted their fathers' failure without hiding behind it or being stopped by it. What makes it hard for you to be honest about the past when you explain what God is doing now?
  2. Tell about a time a matter was cleared up because someone told the facts fairly. What difference did it make?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning