Old Testament1 Samuel 4:3Historical Books

“Wherefore hath the LORD smitten us to day before the Philistines?”

The full verse · 1 Samuel 4:3 · KJV

And when the were into the , the of , Wherefore hath the us to the ? Let us the of the of the out of unto us, that, when it us, it may us out of the of our .

Asked by

Elders

"The elders of Israel" (1 Samuel 4:3)

The Scene

Israel had camped "beside Ebenezer" against the Philistines at Aphek, and in the first battle "Israel was smitten before the Philistines" and about four thousand men were slain; now the people had come back into the camp (1 Samuel 4:1-3).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The elders saw rightly that the defeat had come from the LORD, and they wanted to know why. Keil & Delitzsch connect this with the start of the chapter: "As they had entered upon the war by the word and advice of Samuel, they were convinced that Jehovah had smitten them." (Matthew Henry, by contrast, doubts that Samuel had anything to do with the war.) Keil & Delitzsch call their conclusion that the LORD had withdrawn His help "no doubt a correct conclusion"; Gill agrees they "were right in ascribing it to the Lord," but finds it strange that they missed the reason that was "ready at hand": "their sins and iniquities were the cause of it." Henry reads the question more harshly. He grants, "They own the hand of God in their trouble (so far was right)," but says "it rather seems that they expostulate boldly with God about it," as people unaware of having given Him any cause.

The Response

What Scripture records

The elders did not wait for an answer from God. In the same breath they proposed a plan: "Let us fetch the ark of the covenant of the LORD out of Shiloh unto us, that, when it cometh among us, it may save us" (1 Samuel 4:3). The people sent for it, and Eli's sons Hophni and Phinehas "were there with the ark" (1 Samuel 4:4). The plan failed: "Israel was smitten," thirty thousand footmen fell, "the ark of God was taken," and Hophni and Phinehas were slain (1 Samuel 4:10-11). The book gives the answer later: after the ark had stayed twenty years at Kirjathjearim, Samuel tells Israel to put away "the strange gods" and return to the LORD "with all your hearts" (1 Samuel 7:2-3).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The elders asked a good question and then answered it with a bad plan. Keil & Delitzsch say that instead of repentance and confession, they acted on the "delusive idea" that God had bound His presence so closely to the ark that He would have to come with it and smite the enemy. Gill calls this "foolishly placing their confidence in an external symbol, and not in the Lord himself." Matthew Henry puts the lesson in one line: "though he has bound us to his ark he has not bound himself to it."

The rest of the story bears this out. God let the ark be taken. A psalm looks back on that day: "he forsook the tabernacle of Shiloh... And delivered his strength into captivity, and his glory into the enemy's hand" (Psalms 78:60-61), and centuries later the LORD told Jerusalem, "go ye now unto my place which was in Shiloh... and see what I did to it for the wickedness of my people Israel" (Jeremiah 7:12). Keil & Delitzsch see the purpose of the defeat: the people were to learn that the Lord had departed from them, and Samuel was to discover that Israel's deliverance was "absolutely impossible without its inward conversion to its God." When Israel did return to the LORD, He thundered on the Philistines (1 Samuel 7:3-10), and Samuel named the stone Ebenezer: "Hitherto hath the LORD helped us" (1 Samuel 7:12).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when things go wrong and I ask You why, what would You have me see in my own heart before I rush to my own plan?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The elders asked "wherefore" and then answered with a plan before hearing from God. What do you tend to reach for first when something goes wrong?
  2. When have you seen someone treat a religious habit or object as if it could guarantee God's help, and what did that teach you?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning