Old TestamentJudges 9:2Historical Books

“Whether is better for you, either that all the sons of Jerubbaal, which are threescore and ten persons, reign over you, or that one reign over you?”

The full verse · Judges 9:2 · KJV

, I pray you, in the of all the of , Whether is for you, either that all the of , which are threescore and , over you, or that over you? also that I am your and your .

Asked by

Abimelech Son of Gideon

Speaking through "his mother's brethren" (Judges 9:1)

Asked to

Shechem

"All the men of Shechem" (Judges 9:2)

The Scene

Gideon has died (Judges 8:32), and his son Abimelech goes to his mother's relatives in Shechem and asks them to put this question to all the men of the city (Judges 9:1-2).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Abimelech wanted to rule, and he built his question to make himself look like the only sensible choice. He offered the men of Shechem two options: seventy rulers or one. But no one had proposed seventy rulers. Keil & Delitzsch say plainly, "No such rule ever existed, or was even aspired to by the seventy sons of Gideon." Abimelech, they explain, "assumed that his brothers possessed the same thirst for ruling as he did himself." Gill calls the question "only a wicked insinuation of this man's," aimed at getting the kingdom for himself, and Matthew Henry observes, "Those who design ill themselves are commonly most apt to suspect that others design ill."

Then came his real argument: "remember also that I am your bone and your flesh." Keil & Delitzsch explain the phrase as meaning a blood relation, as in Genesis 29:14. Abimelech's mother lived in Shechem, and her family was there (Judges 8:31; 9:1), so he was asking the city to choose one of its own. Matthew Henry notes that no one in Shechem had thought of him as king first: "None would have dreamed of making such a one king, if he had not dreamed of it himself."

The Response

What Scripture records

The question worked. His mother's brethren repeated his words to the men of Shechem, "and their hearts inclined to follow Abimelech; for they said, He is our brother" (Judges 9:3). They gave him "threescore and ten pieces of silver out of the house of Baalberith," and he hired "vain and light persons" with it (Judges 9:4). He went to Ophrah and "slew his brethren the sons of Jerubbaal, being threescore and ten persons, upon one stone," though Jotham, the youngest, hid himself and escaped (Judges 9:5). Then "all the men of Shechem gathered together, and all the house of Millo," and "made Abimelech king" (Judges 9:6).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

God is not named in Abimelech's question, and that is the point. Gideon had said, "the LORD shall rule over you" (Judges 8:23), but after his death Israel "remembered not the LORD their God" (Judges 8:34). Abimelech asked which arrangement was "better for you," and the men of Shechem answered by kinship: "He is our brother" (Judges 9:3). Gill notes that they made him king "without asking counsel of God," and Matthew Henry says, "God was not consulted whether they should have any king at all."

Yet God was not absent from the story. The chapter ends by saying, "Thus God rendered the wickedness of Abimelech, which he did unto his father, in slaying his seventy brethren: And all the evil of the men of Shechem did God render upon their heads" (Judges 9:56-57). A question that left God out still ended up under God's judgment.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, where might loyalty to my own people or my own ambition be shaping my choices more than what is right in Your sight?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Abimelech offered only two choices. When someone frames a decision for you, how do you check whether those really are the only options?
  2. "He is our brother" settled the matter for Shechem. When have you seen loyalty to "our own" make it hard to see clearly? What helped, or would have helped?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning