Old TestamentJudges 21:3Historical Books

“O LORD God of Israel, why is this come to pass in Israel, that there should be to day one tribe lacking in Israel?”

The full verse · Judges 21:3 · KJV

And , O of , why is this come to pass in , that there should be to in ?

Asked by

Israel

Asked to

God

The Scene

After a war that left only six hundred men of Benjamin alive (Judges 20:47-48), the people came to "the house of God," stayed there "till even before God," and "wept sore" (Judges 21:2).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

This is a cry of grief, not a request for facts. One of the twelve tribes was about to disappear: Benjamin had six hundred men left (Judges 20:47), and the men of Israel had sworn that none of them would give his daughter to Benjamin as a wife (Judges 21:1). Matthew Henry says they wept not so much for the 40,000 of their own men who had fallen "but for the entire destruction of one whole tribe." Keil & Delitzsch say the lament "involved the wish that God might show them the way to avert the threatened destruction of the missing tribe." Gill hears the people pleading with their covenant God, who would "suffer them to expostulate with him" (that is, to reason and plead with Him), and he notes that wiping out the tribe had not been "their intention when they made the above oath."

The Response

What Scripture records

The text records no answer from God. Earlier in this war, when Israel asked counsel, the text says each time, "And the LORD said" (Judges 20:18, 23, 28); here no reply is written. Instead, "on the morrow" the people "rose early, and built there an altar, and offered burnt offerings and peace offerings" (Judges 21:4). Then they began to work on the problem themselves, starting with the question, "Who is there among all the tribes of Israel that came not up with the congregation unto the LORD?" (Judges 21:5).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Israel asks God "why," but the chapters before give a hard answer. The LORD had told them, "Go up; for to morrow I will deliver them into thine hand" (Judges 20:28), and "the LORD smote Benjamin before Israel" (Judges 20:35). Yet it was "the men of Israel" who then struck "the men of every city, as the beast, and all that came to hand" (Judges 20:48), and it was their own oath that kept the survivors from wives (Judges 21:1). Keil & Delitzsch judge that feelings of revenge had carried the army into "a war of extermination which was neither commanded by the law nor justified by the circumstances." Gill looks at it more from the side of providence: though the breach was done by the Israelites, it was "yet by the permission and according to the will of God" (on Judges 21:15).

Both views fit the narrator's own words. He says "the LORD had made a breach in the tribes of Israel" (Judges 21:15), and he closes the book with "every man did that which was right in his own eyes" (Judges 21:25). Matthew Henry draws a lesson from the whole scene: "There may be over-doing in well-doing." He also sees good in where they took their sorrow: "Every thing that grieves us should bring us to God."

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when I grieve a loss that my own choices helped bring about, how can I bring both my sorrow and my part in it honestly to You?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. When something goes wrong, why might it be easier to ask God "why" than to ask what part you played in it?
  2. Matthew Henry says, "Every thing that grieves us should bring us to God." When has a loss drawn you closer to God, or tempted you to pull away?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning