Old TestamentIsaiah 44:19Major Prophets

“And shall I make the residue thereof an abomination?”

The full verse · Isaiah 44:19 · KJV

And none in his , neither is there nor to , I have of it the ; yea, I have upon the thereof; I have , and it: and shall I the thereof an ? shall I fall to the of a ?

Asked by

Isaiah

Voicing what the idol-maker never says, since "none considereth in his heart" (Isaiah 44:19)

Asked to

Idolaters

"They that make a graven image" (Isaiah 44:9)

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Isaiah asks rather than states to force recognition of the glaring contradiction: using half a tree for practical purposes while worshiping the other half exposes idolatry as absurd and self-refuting.

The Response

What Scripture records

The text provides no response because these are rhetorical questions Isaiah poses to expose idolatry’s inherent foolishness. The idolater himself does not ask them and therefore gives no answer. The prophet’s point is precisely that no rational person would voice such questions and proceed with worship, yet idolaters act out this contradiction without reflection.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

These questions form the climax of Isaiah’s devastating satire against idolatry in chapter 44. The prophet voices what an idol-maker should ask himself but never does: can something be both firewood and deity? The Hebrew to’evah for abomination carries ritual defilement weight, the same term used for forbidden practices in Leviticus. Isaiah employs questions rather than direct denunciation because the interrogative form forces hearers to supply the obvious answer themselves, making the critique more penetrating. The word for block, ’ets, is deliberately mundane, just wood, just a tree, stripping away any mystical veneer. The theological weight is profound: humans are so spiritually darkened that they cannot perceive the absurdity of their own actions. This passage doesn’t mock simple foolishness but reveals the terrifying depth of spiritual blindness that prevents people from recognizing self-evident contradictions. Only divine intervention can restore such lost discernment.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning