Old TestamentGenesis 44:4Law/Torah

“Wherefore have ye rewarded evil for good?”

The full verse · Genesis 44:4 · KJV

And when they were gone of the , and not yet far , unto his , , the ; and when thou dost them, unto them, Wherefore have ye ?

Asked by

Joseph's Steward

Speaking the words Joseph gave him, "when thou dost overtake them, say unto them" (Genesis 44:4)

The Scene

At first light Joseph's brothers leave for Canaan with full sacks, while Joseph's silver cup lies hidden, on his orders, in the sack of the youngest; they are barely out of the city when Joseph sends his steward after them (Genesis 44:1-4).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Joseph wanted his brothers stopped and charged as thieves, and the question frames that charge as ingratitude. They had just eaten at his table and been honored there (Genesis 43:33-34), and their sacks had been filled with food (Genesis 44:1). Gill says the steward was to set out the theft as base ingratitude, "as it would have appeared, had it been fact." Matthew Henry notes that the steward charged them with ingratitude and also with folly, since a cup in daily use would soon be missed.

The charge was a test, not a real theft, because Joseph himself had the cup put in the sack (Genesis 44:2). Keil & Delitzsch explain what was at stake: "It would now be seen how they felt in their inmost hearts towards their father's favourite," that is, whether they would give Benjamin up as they had once given up Joseph. Gill likewise says the cup was hidden partly to put Benjamin in apparent danger and see how his brothers would behave toward him.

The Response

What Scripture records

The steward "overtook them, and he spake unto them these same words" (Genesis 44:6). The brothers answered, "Wherefore saith my lord these words? God forbid that thy servants should do according to this thing" (Genesis 44:7). They pointed to the money they had brought back from Canaan and said that whoever had the cup should die and the rest would be bondmen (Genesis 44:8-9). The steward kept only part of their offer: "he with whom it is found shall be my servant; and ye shall be blameless" (Genesis 44:10). The cup was found in Benjamin's sack, and they "rent their clothes" and all returned to the city (Genesis 44:12-13).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The steward's question was a false charge, but it touched an old truth. Years before, these brothers had hated Joseph (Genesis 37:4) and sold him "for twenty pieces of silver" (Genesis 37:28). Later, in a message they sent Joseph in their father's name, they would admit, "they did unto thee evil" (Genesis 50:16-17). The test Joseph set did not create new guilt; it gave them a chance to show whether they had changed. Keil & Delitzsch say the question was whether they would again give up a brother, "or whether they were ready, with unenvying, self-sacrificing love, to give up their own liberty and lives for him. And they stood this test."

The same Hebrew words for evil and good, ra'ah and tovah, appear again at the end of Genesis when Joseph tells these brothers, "ye thought evil against me; but God meant it unto good" (Genesis 50:20). In the story of Joseph, God is quietly at work through everything people do, including their evil. Matthew Henry draws a hopeful lesson from this scene: "We cannot judge what men are by what they have been formerly, nor what they will do by what they have done."

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, You have been good to me in so many ways; where am I slow to answer Your goodness, and how do You want me to respond?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. When someone has been kind to you, what makes it easy or hard to repay that kindness?
  2. Can you share a time when you saw someone respond to a hard test in a way that showed they had truly changed?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning