Old TestamentGenesis 44:16Law/Torah

“What shall we say unto my lord? What shall we speak? Or how shall we clear ourselves?”

The full verse · Genesis 44:16 · KJV

And , What shall we unto my ? what shall we ? or how shall we clear ? hath found the of thy : behold, we are my , both we, and he with the is .

Asked by

Judah

Asked to

Joseph

The Scene

The brothers have fallen before Joseph in his house, and he has demanded, "What deed is this that ye have done?" (Genesis 44:14-15).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Judah's three questions all say the same thing: there is nothing we can say. Keil & Delitzsch put it simply: "Judah made no attempt at a defence." Gill explains the bind they were in. They could not confess the theft, because they knew of none, yet they could not deny it, because the cup had been found. So they were "nonplussed, confounded, knew not what to say." The first two questions ask what words could possibly help; the third asks how they could ever show themselves in the right.

Then Judah names something deeper: "God hath found out the iniquity of thy servants." Keil & Delitzsch take this to mean that God "is now punishing the crime committed against our brother," pointing back to Genesis 42:21. Gill agrees that he meant "particularly the iniquity of selling Joseph." Matthew Henry says "perhaps" this referred to their wrong to Joseph, "for which they thought God was now reckoning with them."

The Response

What Scripture records

Judah went on: "behold, we are my lord's servants, both we, and he also with whom the cup is found" (Genesis 44:16). Joseph would not accept that: "God forbid that I should do so: but the man in whose hand the cup is found, he shall be my servant; and as for you, get you up in peace unto your father" (Genesis 44:17). Keil & Delitzsch say "Joseph would punish mildly and justly." The brothers did not take the way home. "Then Judah came near unto him" to plead for Benjamin (Genesis 44:18).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Judah's words carry more than he knows. On the surface they could sound like a confession about the cup, but Keil & Delitzsch and Gill both take Judah to be speaking about God and about an older sin. On their first trip the brothers had said, "We are verily guilty concerning our brother... therefore is this distress come upon us" (Genesis 42:21). Now Judah stops defending himself and names the hand of God.

There is grace hidden in this moment. The man before whom Judah has no defense is the very brother they wronged, and he is about to say, "be not grieved, nor angry with yourselves" (Genesis 45:5). Matthew Henry notes the irony that their surrender as Joseph's servants fulfills the dreams they once resented: "shalt thou indeed have dominion over us?" (Genesis 37:8).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when I have run out of words to defend myself, what do You want me to say honestly to You?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Judah stopped arguing and spoke of what God had "found out." What makes it hard for you to stop defending yourself?
  2. Can you share a time when admitting a fault opened the door to something better?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning