Old Testament2 Samuel 19:43Historical Books

“Why then did ye despise us, that our advice should not be first had in bringing back our king?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 19:43 · KJV

And the of the of , and , We have in the , and have also more right in than ye: why then did ye us, that our should not be had in bringing our ? And the of the of were than the of the of .

Asked by

Men of Israel

The tribes other than Judah, who claimed "ten parts in the king" (2 Samuel 19:43)

Asked to

Men of Judah

The Scene

At Gilgal, the men of Judah had just defended their escort of the king, and the men of Israel answered back (2 Samuel 19:41-43).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Israel answers Judah's kinship claim with numbers: "We have ten parts in the king." Keil & Delitzsch explain that they counted ten shares "because they formed ten tribes, in opposition to the one tribe of Judah." Their question then names the hurt: Judah had despised them by not consulting them first.

The last clause is read in two ways. The KJV has "that our advice should not be first had." Keil & Delitzsch render it, "and was not my speech the first to fetch back my king?", and point back to 2 Samuel 19:10-11, where Israel did speak first. Gill gives both senses. Israel "thought they ought to have been consulted"; or, as the Targum (an ancient Aramaic translation) puts it, "was not my word first to bring back my king?" Gill adds that "the first motion was from them," as 2 Samuel 19:11 shows.

The Response

What Scripture records

The text gives no words of Judah's reply, only its tone: "And the words of the men of Judah were fiercer than the words of the men of Israel" (2 Samuel 19:43). Keil & Delitzsch say the writer "sums up briefly the further progress of the dispute, for the purpose of appending the account of Sheba's rebellion, to which it gave rise." Then a Benjamite named Sheba, who "happened to be there," blew a trumpet and cried, "We have no part in David... every man to his tents, O Israel," and "every man of Israel went up from after David" (2 Samuel 20:1-2).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Right after the quarrel, the men of Israel went from "We have ten parts in the king" to following Sheba's cry, "We have no part in David" (2 Samuel 20:1). Gill notes it: "thus they, who just before said they had ten parts in him, now had none at all." Matthew Henry sees how fickle crowds can be: "They were lately striving against the king, to drive him out; now they are striving about him, which shall honour him most." Henry, opening the next chapter, sees these new troubles as the fulfilling of the threat "that the sword should never depart from his house" (2 Samuel 12:10).

The same cry would be heard again when the kingdom divided under Rehoboam: "What portion have we in David? neither have we inheritance in the son of Jesse: to your tents, O Israel" (1 Kings 12:16).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, where am I holding a slight so tightly that it could pull me away from people I love?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The men of Israel went from claiming "ten parts" to following the cry of "no part." What helps you keep one hurt from undoing a whole relationship?
  2. Share a time when a small disagreement grew bigger than it needed to. What would you do differently now?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning