Old Testament2 Samuel 19:41Historical Books

“Why have our brethren the men of Judah stolen thee away, and have brought the king, and his household, and all David's men with him, over Jordan?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 19:41 · KJV

And, behold, all the of to the , and unto the , Why have our the of stolen thee , and have the , and his , and all with him, over ?

Asked by

Men of Israel

The tribes other than Judah, who claimed "ten parts in the king" (2 Samuel 19:43)

Asked to

David

The Scene

After crossing the Jordan, "the king went on to Gilgal," escorted by all the people of Judah and half the people of Israel (2 Samuel 19:40).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The tribes of Israel had been the first to talk of bringing the king back (2 Samuel 19:9-11), but Judah had done the escorting. Now the men of Israel felt left out, and their question accuses Judah of taking the king for themselves.

Keil & Delitzsch say they were "annoyed at the fact that the men of Judah had anticipated them," and take "stolen thee away" to mean "fetched thee thus secretly" without telling them. Gill reads it the same way: "secretly, privately, and unknown to them." Matthew Henry adds that Judah's action seemed to cast doubt on Israel's loyalty, "whereas the king himself knew that they had spoken of it before the men of Judah thought of it." He also notes, "It seemed likewise as if they intended to monopolize the king's favours."

The Response

What Scripture records

The men of Israel spoke to the king, but the men of Judah answered: "Because the king is near of kin to us: wherefore then be ye angry for this matter? have we eaten at all of the king's cost? or hath he given us any gift?" (2 Samuel 19:42). Israel answered back, and "the words of the men of Judah were fiercer than the words of the men of Israel" (2 Samuel 19:43). No reply from David is recorded.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

This was not the first time a group in Israel complained about being left out of a victory. The men of Ephraim asked Gideon, "Why hast thou served us thus, that thou calledst us not" (Judges 8:1), and later challenged Jephthah the same way (Judges 12:1). Gideon answered gently, and "their anger was abated toward him" (Judges 8:3); Jephthah's quarrel ended in bloodshed (Judges 12:4-6).

Here, the quarrel would soon split the kingdom again (2 Samuel 20:1-2). Matthew Henry's comment fits the moment: "See what mischief comes from pride and jealousy." Even so, Henry does not put all the blame on Israel: "The men of Judah would have done better if they had taken their brethren's advice and assistance."

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when I feel left out of something good, how can I rejoice in it instead of resenting it?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The men of Israel wanted the king back, yet they felt slighted when others brought him. When has wanting credit gotten in the way of a good thing for you?
  2. Share a time when you felt left out. What helped you move past it?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning