Old Testament2 Samuel 20:9Historical Books

“Art thou in health, my brother?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 20:9 · KJV

And to , Art thou in , my ? And by the with the to him.

Asked by

Joab

Asked to

Amasa

The man David promised to make captain "in the room of Joab" (2 Samuel 19:13)

The Scene

While David's men pursued the rebel Sheba, they met Amasa "at the great stone which is in Gibeon," and Joab came to him with a sword fastened at his loins that "fell out" as he went forth (2 Samuel 20:8).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Joab's friendly question was a cover for murder. Amasa had taken Joab's place: Absalom had "made Amasa captain of the host instead of Joab" (2 Samuel 17:25), and David had promised Amasa he would be captain "continually in the room of Joab" (2 Samuel 19:13). Keil & Delitzsch say plainly, "The reason for this assassination was Joab's jealousy of Amasa."

Gill says Joab spoke "with all the air of pleasantry and good humour," asking after Amasa's health and calling him brother "to cover his design." Matthew Henry says Joab did it "treacherously, and under pretence of friendship, that Amasa might not be upon his guard." Henry pictures Joab holding Amasa's beard to kiss him, "while with the drawn sword in his other hand he was aiming at his heart."

The Response

What Scripture records

Amasa's reply, if he made one, is not recorded. "Amasa took no heed to the sword that was in Joab's hand: so he smote him therewith in the fifth rib, and shed out his bowels to the ground, and struck him not again; and he died" (2 Samuel 20:10). Joab and Abishai went on after Sheba, and one of Joab's men called out, "He that favoureth Joab, and he that is for David, let him go after Joab" (2 Samuel 20:11). Later David reminded Solomon that Joab "shed the blood of war in peace" (1 Kings 2:5), and Solomon said, "the LORD shall return his blood upon his own head" (1 Kings 2:32).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

God is not named in this verse, but the story does not leave Joab's deed unjudged. Matthew Henry notes that Joab had killed Abner the same way "and went unpunished for it, which encouraged him to do the like again" (2 Samuel 3:27). Henry also observes, "The more there is of plot in a sin the worse it is." Joab's planning, his greeting, and his kiss all served one end.

The guilt was finally laid where it belonged. Solomon said Joab "fell upon two men more righteous and better than he" and that "the LORD shall return his blood upon his own head" (1 Kings 2:32). Gill adds a second thought: he sees God's providence in Amasa's death too, since Amasa had joined Absalom's rebellion. Even so, Scripture never excuses the one who struck the blow. Henry says, "the covering of blood with a cloth cannot stop its cry in God's ear for vengeance" (2 Samuel 20:12).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, is there anyone I greet warmly while holding resentment in my heart, and what would it take for my words and my heart to match?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Joab called Amasa "my brother" while resenting that Amasa had his post. What do you do with resentment toward someone who received what you wanted?
  2. When has someone's kindness toward you proved real over time? What made the difference?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning