Old TestamentMalachi 2:17Minor Prophets

“Wherein have we wearied him?”

The full verse · Malachi 2:17 · KJV

Ye have the with your . Yet ye , Wherein have we him? When ye , Every one that is in the of the , and he in them; or, is the of ?

Asked by

Israel

The people's words, quoted by Malachi, "Yet ye say" (Malachi 2:17)

Asked to

Malachi

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Israel uses this question to mock God’s justice, implying either His absence or His moral indifference. By asking rather than affirming, they cast doubt on divine governance while maintaining deniability about outright blasphemy.

The Response

What Scripture records

God’s immediate answer comes through Malachi’s continuing prophecy: He will send His messenger to prepare the way, then suddenly come to His temple as refiner and purifier (Malachi 3:1-3). This demonstrates that the God of justice is both present and coming, working on His own timeline rather than Israel’s impatient demands.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Israel’s question drips with cynical doubt, challenging God’s very existence as moral governor of the universe. The phrase ‘God of justice’ (Elohei hammishpat) invokes covenant promises that the righteous would be vindicated and the wicked punished. By asking ‘where’ rather than ‘why,’ Israel implies divine absence or impotence. The question functions rhetorically to mock God’s apparent failure to fulfill His judicial role. Gill observes that such skepticism arose from observing the wicked prosper while the ostensibly faithful suffered, leading to the perverse conclusion that God either didn’t exist or didn’t care. The question form allows Israel to maintain plausible deniability about outright atheism while effectively denying God’s active governance. This wearied the Lord because it inverted the covenant relationship, treating divine patience as evidence of divine absence.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning