Old TestamentJeremiah 40:15Major Prophets

“Wherefore should he slay thee, that all the Jews which are gathered unto thee should be scattered, and the remnant in Judah perish?”

The full verse · Jeremiah 40:15 · KJV

Then the of to in , , Let me , I pray thee, and I will the of , and no shall it: wherefore should he thee, that all the which are unto thee should be , and the in ?

Asked by

Johanan

Asked to

Gedaliah

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Johanan frames his intelligence report as a question to force Gedaliah to confront the deadly consequences of inaction. By asking rather than simply warning, he shifts the moral weight onto Gedaliah, making him responsible for the scattering and perishing of the Jews if he refuses this preemptive strike.

The Response

What Scripture records

Gedaliah rejected Johanan’s proposal, telling him not to do this thing because he believed Johanan was speaking falsely about Ishmael (Jeremiah 40:16). Gedaliah’s trust in Ishmael proved fatal; Ishmael assassinated him shortly afterward (Jeremiah 41:1-2).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Johanan’s question operates as prophetic warning disguised as strategic counsel. The interrogative lamah (why) in Hebrew doesn’t seek information but protests absurdity; it functions rhetorically to expose the irrationality of allowing assassination to proceed unchecked. By asking rather than demanding, Johanan respects Gedaliah’s authority while making the consequences unbearably clear: one man’s life versus the survival of the entire remnant. The phrase structure links Gedaliah’s death directly to communal catastrophe through Hebrew parallelism, making personal and national fates inseparable. This question carries theological weight precisely because it went unheeded. Gedaliah’s naive trust, however admirable in motive, failed to account for human treachery in a fallen world. The question thus becomes Scripture’s indictment of unwise passivity, demonstrating that godly leadership requires both mercy and discernment, both peace-seeking and protective vigilance.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning