Old TestamentEzekiel 24:19Major Prophets

“Wilt thou not tell us what these things are to us, that thou doest so?”

The full verse · Ezekiel 24:19 · KJV

And the unto me, Wilt thou not us what these things are to us, that thou so?

Asked by

Israel

The people Ezekiel spoke to, whom God calls "the house of Israel" (Ezekiel 24:21)

Asked to

Ezekiel

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The exiles ask rather than demand because they recognize Ezekiel’s bizarre behavior as prophetically significant and seek to understand the symbolic meaning God intends to communicate through the prophet’s refusal to mourn his wife’s death publicly.

The Response

What Scripture records

Ezekiel explained that just as he was forbidden to mourn his wife, the desire of his eyes, so the people would be forbidden to mourn when Jerusalem and the temple, the desire of their eyes, fell, and their sons and daughters were slaughtered. He declared that his behavior was a sign, and when it came to pass, they would do as he had done and would know that he is the Lord God.

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The exiles’ question reveals their recognition that Ezekiel’s behavior carried symbolic weight beyond personal grief. The Hebrew construction uses two interrogative phrases, ‘Wilt thou not tell us’ and ‘what these things are to us’, emphasizing both the urgency of their request and their assumption that the prophet’s actions directly concerned them. They ask rather than assume because prophetic sign-acts required interpretation; the meaning was not self-evident. The double question format reflects genuine perplexity: they see the strangeness but cannot decode the message. This inquiry becomes the interpretive key that unlocks one of Ezekiel’s most powerful enacted prophecies, where personal tragedy becomes national warning. The theological weight rests in God’s use of the prophet’s deepest loss to communicate the nation’s approaching devastation, a pattern where God’s messengers participate bodily in the judgments they proclaim, foreshadowing Christ’s ultimate identification with human suffering.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning