Old TestamentEcclesiastes 3:21Wisdom & Poetry

“Who knoweth the spirit of man that goeth upward, and the spirit of the beast that goeth downward to the earth?”

The full verse · Ecclesiastes 3:21 · KJV

Who the of that , and the of the that to the ?

Asked by

Preacher

Asked to

Reader

The Scene

Having seen "the place of judgment, that wickedness was there" (Ecclesiastes 3:16), the Preacher considers that men and beasts alike die: "they have all one breath" and "all turn to dust again" (Ecclesiastes 3:19-20).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The Preacher has just looked at death from the outside. Men and beasts both die, both breathe, and both return to dust (Ecclesiastes 3:19-20). His question asks whether anyone can see, from here, what happens to the spirit after that.

The commentators read the question in two ways. Keil & Delitzsch translate it "whether it mounteth upward" and "whether it goeth downward," and say the context "requires a sceptical question": in this passage, they say, the Preacher "remains in doubt." Yet they add that by the end of the book, "we see from xii. 7 that this faith held sway over Koheleth" (Koheleth is the Hebrew name for the Preacher).

Gill and Matthew Henry read it as the KJV does: there is a real difference, the spirit of man goes upward and the beast's goes down, but who knows it? Gill says no one sees it with bodily eyes, or knows it clearly by reason alone "without a divine revelation." Both also give a second sense, which Gill prefers ("or rather"): who knows and considers this difference? Henry puts it, "Who knows, that is, who considers this?... Very few."

The Response

What Scripture records

The Preacher does not answer right away. He draws a practical conclusion instead: "Wherefore I perceive that there is nothing better, than that a man should rejoice in his own works... for who shall bring him to see what shall be after him?" (Ecclesiastes 3:22).

The book gives a clearer word near its end. Describing death, the Preacher says, "Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was: and the spirit shall return unto God who gave it" (Ecclesiastes 12:7).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Ecclesiastes 3:16-22 begins with injustice and ends with death. The Preacher first says, "God shall judge the righteous and the wicked" (Ecclesiastes 3:17), then admits that by looking at death alone, "a man hath no preeminence above a beast" (Ecclesiastes 3:19). Keil & Delitzsch observe that if one "loses sight of God, the distinction between the life of man and of beast disappears." The question shows the limit of what can be known "under the sun."

The book does not leave the question there. Its last word on death is that "the spirit shall return unto God who gave it" (Ecclesiastes 12:7), and its last word on life is that "God shall bring every work into judgment" (Ecclesiastes 12:14). Keil & Delitzsch say that in the end "it is faith which solves the dilemma." Matthew Henry's concise note asks how "an eternity of existence may be to us an eternity of enjoyment," and says that to answer this "is the grand design of revelation."

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, the Preacher could not see past death with his own eyes, and neither can I. What do You want me to understand about the life You breathed into me and where it is going?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. When you think about death, what questions come up for you that you rarely say out loud?
  2. The Preacher was honest about what he could not see. How has honesty about your questions helped or hindered your faith?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning