Old Testament2 Samuel 14:19Historical Books

“Is not the hand of Joab with thee in all this?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 14:19 · KJV

And the , Is not the of with thee in all this? And the and , As thy , my the , turn to the right or to the from ought that my the hath : for thy , he me, and he all these in the of thine :

Asked by

David

The Scene

After the woman turned her story toward the king's "banished" son and praised him as "an angel of God," David said, "Hide not from me, I pray thee, the thing that I shall ask thee" (2 Samuel 14:13-18).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Her speech was too skilful to be the plea of a poor widow, and David saw who must be behind it. Keil & Delitzsch say her words were "so well considered and so crafty, that the king could not fail to see both what she really meant, and also that she had not come with her petition of her own accord." Matthew Henry explains why David thought of Joab: "he knew none so likely to set her on as Joab, who was a politic man and a friend of Absalom."

Keil & Delitzsch add a reason from what follows. When Joab thanked the king for granting "the request of his servant" (2 Samuel 14:22), they judge it "pretty evident from this, that Joab had frequently applied to David for Absalom's return, without any attention being paid to his application," and that "David therefore suspected that Joab had instructed the woman of Tekoah."

The Response

What Scripture records

She admitted it at once. Beginning, "As thy soul liveth, my lord the king," she said that no one could turn "to the right hand or to the left" from what the king had said: "for thy servant Joab, he bade me, and he put all these words in the mouth of thine handmaid" (2 Samuel 14:19). Joab had done it "To fetch about this form of speech," she said, and she praised the king's wisdom as "the wisdom of an angel of God" (2 Samuel 14:20). David then said to Joab, "go therefore, bring the young man Absalom again," and Joab bowed to the ground and thanked him (2 Samuel 14:21-22).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

David's question uncovered the man behind the plan, and the rest of the story shows how Joab's plan turned out. Keil & Delitzsch sum it up: "the issue of events frustrated all such hopes. Absalom did not succeed to the throne, Joab did not escape punishment, and David was severely chastised for his weakness and injustice." Absalom rose against his father (2 Samuel 15:10-14), Joab himself thrust three darts through Absalom's heart (2 Samuel 18:14), and David later charged Solomon about Joab's bloodshed (1 Kings 2:5-6).

The woman's answer also stands out. She had played a part, but when the king asked her directly, she told the truth. Matthew Henry admires this: she "speaks the truth as it was, and gives us an example to do likewise, and never to tell a lie for the concealing of a well-managed scheme. Dare to be true; nothing can need a lie."

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when I have been carrying someone else's script, what would it look like for me to answer plainly and truthfully?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The woman spoke words someone else had written for her. When have you felt pressure to say what others wanted, and what helped you find your own honest voice?
  2. David noticed the person behind a persuasive appeal. What helps you recognize when you are being steered toward a decision?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning