Old Testament2 Samuel 14:13Historical Books

“Wherefore then hast thou thought such a thing against the people of God?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 14:13 · KJV

And the , Wherefore then hast thou such a thing against the of ? for the doth this as one which is , in that the doth not fetch home his .

Asked to

David

The Scene

After David swore, "As the LORD liveth, there shall not one hair of thy son fall to the earth," the woman asked to "speak one word unto my lord the king," and he said, "Say on" (2 Samuel 14:11-12).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

She had what she came for: a sworn ruling that a son who killed his brother would be spared (2 Samuel 14:11). Now she turned that ruling on the king. Gill puts it this way: "Having gained her point, and gotten a decree from him confirmed by an oath," she went on "to accommodate the parable, and apply it to the case of Absalom." Her charge was that the king spoke "as one which is faulty, in that the king doth not fetch home again his banished" (2 Samuel 14:13). He would protect her son but not his own.

She never named Absalom. Keil & Delitzsch say her words "were intentionally kept indefinite, rather hinting at what she wished to place before the king, than expressing it distinctly." They take "such a thing" to mean "such thoughts as thou hast towards thy son, whose blood-guiltiness thou wilt not forgive," and "the people of God" as "members of the congregation of God." Gill reports other readings, then prefers this: the king's course was "contrary to the will of the people of Israel, the people of God," who wanted Absalom brought back. Matthew Henry hears the same plea: "What is done against him is done against the people of God."

The commentators read David's own heart differently. Gill and Henry take Joab's insight that "the king's heart was toward Absalom" (2 Samuel 14:1) to mean David still loved him and wanted a way to bring him back. Keil & Delitzsch argue the Hebrew means the king's heart was "against" Absalom, noting that even after the return David would not see him for two full years (2 Samuel 14:24, 28). Gill also reports this view from Abarbinel and the Targum, an ancient Aramaic translation. Either way, the woman's task was to move the king to act.

The Response

What Scripture records

The woman kept speaking. She reminded the king, "we must needs die, and are as water spilt on the ground," and said of God, "yet doth he devise means, that his banished be not expelled from him" (2 Samuel 14:14). Then she praised him "as an angel of God" (2 Samuel 14:15-17). David answered with a question of his own: "Is not the hand of Joab with thee in all this?" (2 Samuel 14:18-19). When she admitted it, he told Joab, "go therefore, bring the young man Absalom again" (2 Samuel 14:21). But once Absalom was back in Jerusalem, the king said, "let him not see my face" (2 Samuel 14:23-24).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The woman's question reached for something true about God. She said of Him, "yet doth he devise means, that his banished be not expelled from him" (2 Samuel 14:14). Keil & Delitzsch sum up her point: God "does not deprive the sinner of life, but is merciful, and does not cast off for ever." Matthew Henry finds here "two great instances of the mercy of God to sinners": His patience with them, and His provision to restore them. He writes, "The state of sinners is a state of banishment from God." Henry goes further and says that David's recall of Absalom only "upon intercession made for him" "may illustrate the methods of divine grace": "God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself."

But the chapter also shows the limits of her argument. Henry's concise note warns that "God pardons none to the dishonour of his law and justice, nor any who are impenitent." Henry says plainly, "I see not how David can be justified in suspending the execution of the ancient law." David brought Absalom home without dealing with his guilt or his heart, and Keil & Delitzsch judge that "This half forgiveness was an imprudent measure, and bore very bitter fruit." Within two chapters Absalom would steal "the hearts of the men of Israel" and drive his father from Jerusalem (2 Samuel 15:6, 14). God's mercy is real, and it never sets aside His justice.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, You devise means so that the banished are not expelled from You; how can I hold mercy and justice together the way You do?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The woman got David to judge someone else's case before he saw his own. Why is it often easier to see what is right in someone else's situation than in yours?
  2. Share a time when a story, or someone's honest question, helped you see your own situation more clearly.

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning