Old Testament2 Samuel 13:20Historical Books

“Hath Amnon thy brother been with thee?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 13:20 · KJV

And her unto her, Hath thy been with thee? but hold now thy , my : he is thy ; not this . So in her .

The Scene

After Amnon forced Tamar and had her put out, she tore her royal robe, put ashes on her head, and went away crying, and her brother Absalom spoke to her (2 Samuel 13:14-20).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Absalom saw his sister in open grief and guessed the cause. Keil & Delitzsch call his question "a euphemism for what had taken place," a gentle way of saying it, and note this was what "Absalom immediately conjectured." Gill says he guessed it "having heard of her being sent to his house" and "seeing her in such a forlorn condition." Matthew Henry goes further: "It should seem" from the question "that Amnon was notorious for such lewd practices." The rest of the verse shows that Absalom was already thinking ahead: he told her to keep quiet.

The Response

What Scripture records

No answer from Tamar is recorded. Absalom went on, "but hold now thy peace, my sister: he is thy brother; regard not this thing," and "Tamar remained desolate in her brother Absalom's house" (2 Samuel 13:20). Absalom said nothing to Amnon, "neither good nor bad: for Absalom hated Amnon, because he had forced his sister Tamar" (2 Samuel 13:22). "After two full years" he had Amnon killed (2 Samuel 13:23, 28-29).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Absalom's words sounded like comfort, but the text shows what was underneath: "Absalom hated Amnon" (2 Samuel 13:22). Keil & Delitzsch explain that "Absalom quieted the sister, because he was determined to take revenge, but wished to conceal his plan of vengeance for the time." Gill agrees that he spoke "not out of love of Amnon, but as desirous of gratifying private revenge." Matthew Henry sets this against the law: "rebuking our neighbour is opposed to hating him in our hearts" (Leviticus 19:17), and, citing 1 John 3:15, adds that "he that hateth his brother is a murderer" already.

Tamar received little help from either man with power to act. Her brother told her to be silent, and her father "was very wroth" but the text records nothing more (2 Samuel 13:21). Henry does not condemn Absalom's hatred of the crime itself; he says it "would have been commendable, and he might justly have prosecuted him for it by a due course of law." The sin lay in hating the person and taking revenge in secret.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when someone I love is wronged, how can I keep my anger from becoming the hidden hatred that Absalom carried?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Absalom's words to Tamar sounded calming, but hatred was underneath. Why can quiet words sometimes hide something harmful?
  2. What does it look like to stand with someone who has been hurt without telling them to keep quiet?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning