Old Testament2 Chronicles 28:10Historical Books

“But are there not with you, even with you, sins against the LORD your God?”

The full verse · 2 Chronicles 28:10 · KJV

And now ye to keep the of and for and unto you: but are there not with you, with you, against the your ?

Asked by

Oded

"A prophet of the LORD" in Samaria (2 Chronicles 28:9)

Asked to

Army

Israel's army, "the host that came to Samaria" with captives from Judah (2 Chronicles 28:9)

The Scene

In the days of King Ahaz, Pekah king of Israel struck Judah, and the children of Israel carried away "two hundred thousand, women, sons, and daughters" toward Samaria, where the prophet Oded went out to meet the returning army (2 Chronicles 28:5-9).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Oded wanted the victors to see themselves as God saw them. He had just told them that they won only "because the LORD God of your fathers was wroth with Judah," and that they had slain their brothers "in a rage that reacheth up unto heaven" (2 Chronicles 28:9). Now they planned to keep the people of Judah "for bondmen and bondwomen" (2 Chronicles 28:10). His question turns their eyes from Judah's guilt to their own.

Keil & Delitzsch explain that the Hebrew stresses "you" twice, as if to say, "Have you, to regard only you, not also burdened yourselves with many sins against the Lord?" They call the question "a lively way of expressing assurance as to a matter which is not at all doubtful." Gill adds that for these sins Israel deserved to be chastised as well as Judah, "and might expect it." Matthew Henry says Oded "appeals to their own consciences," checking both their pride in victory and their severity toward their brethren.

The Response

What Scripture records

The answer was plain, and Oded pressed it home: "deliver the captives again... for the fierce wrath of the LORD is upon you" (2 Chronicles 28:11). Four heads of the children of Ephraim then stood up against the returning soldiers and said, "Ye shall not bring in the captives hither: for whereas we have offended against the LORD already, ye intend to add more to our sins and to our trespass" (2 Chronicles 28:12-13). "So the armed men left the captives and the spoil before the princes and all the congregation" (2 Chronicles 28:14). The men "expressed by name" clothed the naked, gave them food and drink, anointed them, "carried all the feeble of them upon asses," and brought them to Jericho "to their brethren" (2 Chronicles 28:15).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

God had used Israel to correct Judah, but being God's rod did not make Israel righteous. Matthew Henry puts it this way: Israel won "not because God favoured them," but because He was angry with Judah, and he ties this to Moses' warning, "Not for thy righteousness" (Deuteronomy 9:5), and to Paul's "Be not highminded, but fear" (Romans 11:20). The same God who judged Judah's sin saw the rage and the plans of the victors, and He sent a prophet to stop them before they added more guilt.

The story ends with unexpected mercy. Keil & Delitzsch compare it to the time Shemaiah told the army of Judah, "ye shall not go up, nor fight against your brethren" (2 Chronicles 11:4), and they obeyed. Here the northern leaders obeyed God's word and sent the captives home clothed and fed. Gill says that in all this these people of Samaria "acted the part of the good Samaritan" (Luke 10:33). Henry also notes the sad limit of their obedience: they heeded the prophet in this, yet did not root out the idolatry that soon ruined their kingdom.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when I see someone else being corrected or brought low, what in my own heart do You want me to see before I judge them?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Oded asked the victors, "are there not with you, even with you, sins against the LORD your God?" (2 Chronicles 28:10). Why is it so easy to see another person's sin most clearly when they are the one who has fallen?
  2. When have you seen someone show mercy to a person who was down, when they could have kept them under? What did it look like?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning