Old Testament1 Samuel 17:29Historical Books

“What have I now done? Is there not a cause?”

The full verse · 1 Samuel 17:29 · KJV

And , What have I now ? Is there not a ?

Asked by

David

Asked to

Eliab

David's "eldest brother" (1 Samuel 17:28)

The Scene

Eliab had just accused David of pride and of coming down only "that thou mightest see the battle" (1 Samuel 17:28), and David answers him there in the camp.

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

David answers his brother's attack without matching his anger. "What have I now done?" asks Eliab to name an actual wrong. "Is there not a cause?" defends his words, though the commentators read it in two ways. Gill thinks David meant there was good reason, either for his coming, "being sent by his father," or for his anger at the Philistine's defiance; he mentions the Targum's reading, "is it not a word only which I have spoken?" but says "the former sense seems best." Keil & Delitzsch take the other reading, "It was only a word," and say David "answered very modestly, and so as to put the scorn of his reprover to shame." Matthew Henry gives both senses of "cause": his father sent him, and Goliath's insult deserved a response.

The Response

What Scripture records

The text records no reply from Eliab. David did not stay to argue: "he turned from him toward another, and spake after the same manner: and the people answered him again after the former manner" (1 Samuel 17:30). His words spread until "they rehearsed them before Saul: and he sent for him" (1 Samuel 17:31). The next time David speaks, it is to the king: "thy servant will go and fight with this Philistine" (1 Samuel 17:32).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Before David fought Goliath, he had to get past his own brother's contempt, and he did it with two short questions and a turn of the shoulder. Matthew Henry treats it as a real conquest: "This conquest of his own passion was in some respects more honourable than his conquest of Goliath." He also notes, "It was no time for David to quarrel with his brother when the Philistines were upon them."

The chapter keeps David's attention on the real enemy. Gill thinks David's repeated questions were meant to reach Saul, "to whom in modesty he did not choose to apply himself," and that is what happened (1 Samuel 17:31). David's question echoes later in the book, when he is hunted by Saul and asks Jonathan, "What have I done? what is mine iniquity?" (1 Samuel 20:1). He would ask it again (1 Samuel 26:18; 29:8).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Father, when someone close to me misjudges me, how can I answer honestly without letting it pull me away from what You have given me to do?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. David answered with two short questions and then "turned from him." When is it wiser to step away from an argument than to win it?
  2. Tell about a time someone answered you gently when you were harsh. What did their answer do?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning