Old Testament1 Samuel 11:12Historical Books

“Who is he that said, Shall Saul reign over us?”

The full verse · 1 Samuel 11:12 · KJV

And the unto , Who is he that , Shall over us? the , that we may put them to .

Asked by

Israel

Asked to

Samuel

The Scene

After Saul's army has routed the Ammonites at Jabeshgilead "until the heat of the day" (1 Samuel 11:11), the people come to Samuel.

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

The people wanted to find and punish the men who had scorned Saul. Keil & Delitzsch and Gill both say the question points back to "the children of Belial" at Mizpeh, who said, "How shall this man save us?" and "brought him no presents" (1 Samuel 10:27). Now Saul had saved Jabesh, and the people said, "bring the men, that we may put them to death" (1 Samuel 11:12). Keil & Delitzsch say the people "were so enthusiastic in his favour" after the victory. Gill describes them as "so transported were they with affection to Saul, and indignation against those men." Matthew Henry thinks they took the matter to Samuel as judge because they knew Saul "would not be judge in his own cause," and he notes that they had not dared to speak against Saul's critics while Saul still "looked mean."

The Response

What Scripture records

No reply from Samuel is recorded. Instead "Saul said, There shall not a man be put to death this day: for to day the LORD hath wrought salvation in Israel" (1 Samuel 11:13). Gill and Matthew Henry both read this as Saul speaking before Samuel could answer. Samuel then turned the people's attention elsewhere: "Come, and let us go to Gilgal, and renew the kingdom there" (1 Samuel 11:14). At Gilgal "they made Saul king before the LORD," offered peace offerings, and "Saul and all the men of Israel rejoiced greatly" (1 Samuel 11:15).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The people asked who had doubted Saul, but Saul pointed them to the LORD. The scoffers had asked how this man could save them (1 Samuel 10:27). Saul's answer was that the LORD had brought salvation that day (1 Samuel 11:13), so it was not a day for killing. Keil & Delitzsch say this showed "not only his magnanimity, but also his genuine piety." In a footnote they quote Sebastian Schmidt, who saw in Saul's words a call to follow God's example: since the LORD had overlooked their sins and given them victory, they should "forgive their neighbours' sins without bloodshed."

Matthew Henry adds that "If an enemy be made a friend, that will be more to our advantage than to have him slain." In his concise notes he also sees a picture of Christ here: "The once despised Saviour will at length be acknowledged by all as the Lord's own anointed king." Gill gives a sober note: "it plainly appears that this temper did not always continue with him." Later Saul would vow death on his own son, and the people would have to rescue Jonathan (1 Samuel 14:44-45).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when You have been good to me, is there someone I am still waiting to see paid back, and how would You have me treat them?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. The people's joy over Saul's victory quickly turned into a demand for punishment. Why do you think winning can make people less merciful instead of more?
  2. When has someone shown you mercy at a moment when they could have paid you back? What did it do in you?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning