Old Testament1 Kings 1:6Historical Books

“Why hast thou done so?”

The full verse · 1 Kings 1:6 · KJV

And his had not him at any in , Why hast thou done ? and he also was a man; and his mother him .

Asked by

David

A question David never asked his son, for he "had not displeased him at any time" (1 Kings 1:6)

Asked to

Adonijah

The Scene

King David was old, and though they covered him with clothes "he gat no heat," when his son Adonijah declared, "I will be king," and gathered "chariots and horsemen, and fifty men to run before him" (1 Kings 1:1-5). The narrator stops to explain what lay behind this.

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

This is a question David never asked. The narrator says his father "had not displeased him at any time in saying, Why hast thou done so?" (1 Kings 1:6). It is the simple question a father asks to call a son to account, and its absence explains Adonijah's boldness in 1 Kings 1:5. Keil & Delitzsch put it plainly: "Such weak oversight on the part of his father encouraged him to make the present attempt." Gill says David "never so much as asked a reason of his conduct, so far was he from reproving him for it," and counts this "not to the credit of David, being guilty of the same sin with Eli." Matthew Henry places blame on both sides: the son resented correction, and "it was the father's fault that, because he saw it displeased him, he did not reprove him."

The Response

What Scripture records

Because the question was never asked, there was no answer. The text shows instead where its absence led. Adonijah "conferred with Joab ... and with Abiathar the priest," and his guests feasted and said, "God save king Adonijah" (1 Kings 1:7, 25). When Solomon was anointed instead, Adonijah "caught hold on the horns of the altar" and was sent home on one condition: "if wickedness shall be found in him, he shall die" (1 Kings 1:50-53). Later he asked for Abishag the Shunammite as his wife, and Solomon had him put to death (1 Kings 2:17, 24-25).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

The verse explains a human failure, but the chapter shows God's choice standing firm. Adonijah's claim rested on birth order and good looks (1 Kings 1:6). Keil & Delitzsch point out that "in Israel, Jehovah, the God-King of His people, had reserved to Himself the choice of the earthly king" (Deuteronomy 17:15), and God had already made Solomon known: when he was born, "the LORD loved him," and through Nathan named him Jedidiah (2 Samuel 12:24-25). By the end, even Adonijah admits the kingdom was Solomon's: "for it was his from the LORD" (1 Kings 2:15).

The narrator's comment also shows how one failure can repeat in a family. Adonijah copied Absalom's chariots and runners (2 Samuel 15:1; 1 Kings 1:5), and Gill compares David's silence with Eli, who saw his sons sin and "restrained them not" (1 Samuel 3:13). Matthew Henry draws the lesson: "Those who honour their sons more than God, as those do who keep them not under good discipline, thereby forfeit the honour they might expect from their sons." Yet the story does not end with David's weakness. When the crisis came, David kept his oath and set Solomon on the throne (1 Kings 1:29-35).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Father, where have I avoided asking a loving but hard question, and where am I resisting the questions You and others ask of me?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Matthew Henry says the son was wrong to resent correction and the father wrong to hold it back. Which of those two comes more naturally to you, and why?
  2. Think of someone who cared enough to ask you, "Why did you do that?" What did their question do for you?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning