A. Job laments his miserable comforters.
1. (1-5) Job reproaches his pitiless friends.
Then Job answered and said: “I have heard many such things; Miserable comforters are you all! Shall words of wind have an end? Or what provokes you that you answer? I also could speak as you do, If your soul were in my soul’s place. I could heap up words against you, And shake my head at you; But I would strengthen you with my mouth, And the comfort of my lips would relieve your grief.”
a. I have heard many such things: Job reminded his critics that all they gave him was the “conventional wisdom” explanation of an absolute relationship of cause and effect to make sense of his suffering. Job’s friends said, “Everyone knows these things” (as in Job 15:14-15); Job’s response was, “It is all what we have heard before; I have heard many such things.”
i. “These sayings of the ancients are not strange to me; but they do not apply to my case: ye see me in affliction, ye should endeavour to console me. This ye do not; and yet ye pretend to do it! Miserable comforters are ye all.” (Clarke)
b. Miserable comforters are you all: Job hoped this reproach would shame his accusers into seeing just how greatly they failed to help him. Their too-great confidence in their own wisdom made them unable to properly sympathize with Job. They did much better in the days when they simply sat silently with the suffering Job (Job 2:11-13).
i. Trapp attempted to capture the heart of Job’s complaint: “You charge me for slighting the consolations of God, and pretend to come purposely to comfort me; but such cold comforters I have seldom met with; for instead of abating and allaying my sorrows, you do all you can to increase and heighten them. Is this your kindness to your friend?”
ii. “Job, with purpose, chose a word (amal) Eliphaz used to suggest Job had conceived his own misery (‘trouble,’ Job 15:35); and he threw it back at him in the epithet ‘miserable comforters’ (Job 16:2).” (Smick)
c. Shall words of wind have an end: Job just wanted his friends to stop their windy speeches, full of condemnation. It seems that this part of Job’s trial was as severe as the losses described in Job 1 and 2.
i. “The chief reason for being suspicious of the theology of Job’s friends is that it is so obviously lacking in mercy.” (Mason)
d. I also could speak as you do… I could heap up words against you, and shake my head at you: Job recognized that he could indeed be in the same place of unsympathetic condemnation towards his friends as they were towards him. Yet he also saw that his suffering had changed his perspective and would now instead strengthen and comfort them.
i. “The folly of criticizing sorrow from the vantage point of prosperity is declared. Job said that he could speak as they if they were in his place, but he would not do it. He would attempt to strengthen them.” (Morgan)
ii. One of the great advantages of personal suffering is that it makes the sufferer far more sympathetic towards others who suffer. Those who otherwise would have been harsh and strict towards those suffering will often find themselves much more willing to give strength and comfort towards others who suffer similar grief (2 Corinthians 1:3-4).