New TestamentJohn 9:16Gospels

“How can a man that is a sinner do such miracles?”

The full verse · John 9:16 · KJV

the , , he the sabbath . , a that is a ? there a .

Asked by

Pharisees

Some of the Pharisees, divided over the healing (John 9:16)

The Scene

The healed man has been brought to the Pharisees and has told them how he received his sight; John notes it was the sabbath day when Jesus made the clay (John 9:13-15).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Some Pharisees had already ruled against Jesus: "This man is not of God, because he keepeth not the sabbath day." Others could not make that verdict fit the facts. Their question presses a simple point: a sinner could not do works like these. Barnes says the miracles were such as "could not be denied, nor did even the enemies of Jesus attempt to deny them." He says the first group reasoned from their own reading of the Sabbath law, a common error: "Men often assume their own interpretations of the Scriptures to be infallible." Gill suggests those who asked this question "may be supposed to be Nicodemus and Joseph of Arimathea," offered only as a possibility.

The Response

What Scripture records

No one answered the question. Instead, "there was a division among them" (John 9:16). Unable to agree, they turned to the healed man: "What sayest thou of him?" (John 9:17). Later the healed man answered their question with the same reasoning: "If this man were not of God, he could do nothing" (John 9:33). The split did not end here: "There was a division therefore again among the Jews" (John 10:19), and some asked, "Can a devil open the eyes of the blind?" (John 10:21).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Jesus had said this man was born blind "that the works of God should be made manifest in him" (John 9:3). Now those works forced a decision. The same facts produced two verdicts: one group judged Jesus by their rule, and the other let the work in front of them question the rule. Matthew Henry notes that "his enemies could find nothing against him, but the oft-refuted charge of breaking the sabbath." In his full commentary he sees God's hand even in the split: "Thus God defeats the counsels of his enemies by dividing them."

Nicodemus had reasoned the same way earlier: "no man can do these miracles that thou doest, except God be with him" (John 3:2). The question still invites anyone to let what God does correct what we assume.

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Father, where might I be judging Your work by my own rules, and what do You want me to see that I have been missing?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. When something good doesn't fit your idea of how God works, what is your first reaction?
  2. Tell about a time you changed your mind about something because of what you saw God do.

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning