A. Defeat at Ai.
1. (1) Not all of Israel obeyed the law of the devoted things.
But the children of Israel committed a trespass regarding the accursed things, for Achan the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, took of the accursed things; so the anger of the LORD burned against the children of Israel.
a. The children of Israel committed a trespass regarding the accursed things: Joshua commanded the nation in Joshua 6:18-19 that they should not take of any of the accursed things. These included objects associated with the demonic and debasing worship and practices of the Canaanites, and treasures that were only for the house of the LORD.
i. The chapter begins with the word but connecting it to the last verse of Joshua 6, which spoke of Joshua’s spreading fame. “There is an intentional contrast. Although Joshua’s fame spread because of Jericho, Israel’s unfaithfulness provoked God’s anger.” (Hess) A leader of God’s work may enjoy great fame and attention, while sin works its deadly rot among the people of God.
ii. “We must learn from this that God takes sin seriously, even if we do not, and that sin is the real cause of defeat for God’s people.” (Boice)
iii. Committed a trespass: “More generally, the sin was that Israel ‘acted unfaithfully’ with regard to the things devoted to destruction. The term in question here (ml) is used to describe a wife’s adultery (see Numbers 5:12–13): it was a betrayal of a trust that existed between two parties.” (Howard)
b. The accursed things: The wars fought by Israel in Canaan were not fought as plundering wars of personal gain; they were an unusual, sacred instrument in God’s hand, used for judgment against a society over-ripe for judgment. Therefore, the spoil or plunder of Jericho was either regarded as accursed or as specially devoted to the LORD.
i. “God owned the devoted things (ḥerem) in the capture of Jericho (Joshua 6:18–19, 24). To take God’s property is theft. The denial of the theft is deceit…. Either Israel must destroy the devoted things that it possesses or it will be destroyed as devoted things.” (Hess)
c. So the anger of the LORD burned against: Israel’s disobedience brought the anger of God against them. Israel could not be defeated by the Canaanites, but they could defeat themselves by their disobedience, inviting the corrective judgment of God.
i. “It is certain that one only was guilty; and yet the trespass is imputed here to the whole congregation; and the whole congregation soon suffered shame and disgrace on the account.” (Clarke)