3. (17:1-2) Distribution of the land among the remaining families of the tribe of Manasseh.

There was also a lot for the tribe of Manasseh, for he was the firstborn of Joseph: namely for Machir the firstborn of Manasseh, the father of Gilead, because he was a man of war; therefore he was given Gilead and Bashan. And there was a lot for the rest of the children of Manasseh according to their families: for the children of Abiezer, the children of Helek, the children of Asriel, the children of Shechem, the children of Hepher, and the children of Shemida; these were the male children of Manasseh the son of Joseph according to their families.

4. (17:3-6) The inheritance of Zelophehad’s daughters.

But Zelophehad the son of Hepher, the son of Gilead, the son of Machir, the son of Manasseh, had no sons, but only daughters. And these are the names of his daughters: Mahlah, Noah, Hoglah, Milcah, and Tirzah. And they came near before Eleazar the priest, before Joshua the son of Nun, and before the rulers, saying, “The LORD commanded Moses to give us an inheritance among our brothers.” Therefore, according to the commandment of the LORD, he gave them an inheritance among their father’s brothers. Ten shares fell to Manasseh, besides the land of Gilead and Bashan, which were on the other side of the Jordan, because the daughters of Manasseh received an inheritance among his sons; and the rest of Manasseh’s sons had the land of Gilead.

a. Zelophehad…had no sons, but only daughters: This is noted in the text because it was unusual for women to receive an inheritance. It was more important that the land remain in the ancestral families than it was to follow the custom that only males should inherit land. Therefore, the daughters of Zelophehad could inherit their father’s land.

b. The LORD commanded Moses to give us an inheritance among our brothers: This was the implementation of a decision arrived at by Moses in Numbers 27:1-11.

i. It was significant that they carried out what God commanded Moses, as recorded in His word. “They regarded the Pentateuch as the Word of God and as something that not only conveyed some sort of religious feeling, but also gave specific commands that were to be obeyed in detail. They were referring to Numbers 27:1–11 and to Numbers 36.” (Schaeffer)

5. (17:7-13) The boundaries of the western half-tribe of Manasseh and their incomplete occupation of that land.

And the territory of Manasseh was from Asher to Michmethath, that lies east of Shechem; and the border went along south to the inhabitants of En Tappuah. Manasseh had the land of Tappuah, but Tappuah on the border of Manasseh belonged to the children of Ephraim. And the border descended to the Brook Kanah, southward to the brook. These cities of Ephraim are among the cities of Manasseh. The border of Manasseh was on the north side of the brook; and it ended at the sea. Southward it was Ephraim’s, northward it was Manasseh’s, and the sea was its border. Manasseh’s territory was adjoining Asher on the north and Issachar on the east. And in Issachar and in Asher, Manasseh had Beth Shean and its towns, Ibleam and its towns, the inhabitants of Dor and its towns, the inhabitants of En Dor and its towns, the inhabitants of Taanach and its towns, and the inhabitants of Megiddo and its towns—three hilly regions. Yet the children of Manasseh could not drive out the inhabitants of those cities, but the Canaanites were determined to dwell in that land. And it happened, when the children of Israel grew strong, that they put the Canaanites to forced labor, but did not utterly drive them out.

a. Yet the children of Manasseh could not drive out the inhabitants of those cities: Their failure was after the same pattern as the failure of the tribe of Ephraim in Joshua 16:10.

b. But the Canaanites were determined to dwell in that land: It isn’t a surprise that the Canaanites would be determined to remain in the land. What was lacking was complete determination from the people of Israel. They were satisfied to put the Canaanites to forced labor instead of driving them out.

i. “They had the power to remove the Canaanites from the land and so to be God’s instruments of judgment to remove wickedness, but they chose to tolerate wickedness and to use for their own purposes that which God had devoted to destruction. And so they sowed the seeds of their own destruction.” (Howard)

c. Some notable cities in the territory of Western Manasseh: En Dor, Beth Shean, and Megiddo.

6. (17:14-18) Joshua answers the complaint of the tribes of Joseph.

Then the children of Joseph spoke to Joshua, saying, “Why have you given us only one lot and one share to inherit, since we are a great people, inasmuch as the LORD has blessed us until now?” So Joshua answered them, “If you are a great people, then go up to the forest country and clear a place for yourself there in the land of the Perizzites and the giants, since the mountains of Ephraim are too confined for you.” But the children of Joseph said, “The mountain country is not enough for us; and all the Canaanites who dwell in the land of the valley have chariots of iron, both those who are of Beth Shean and its towns and those who are of the Valley of Jezreel.” And Joshua spoke to the house of Joseph—to Ephraim and Manasseh—saying, “You are a great people and have great power; you shall not have only one lot, but the mountain country shall be yours. Although it is wooded, you shall cut it down, and its farthest extent shall be yours; for you shall drive out the Canaanites, though they have iron chariots and are strong.”

a. Why have you given us only one lot and one share to inherit, since we are a great people: Manasseh and Ephraim were large tribes. Their combined number was greater than any other single tribe. Yet they complained that they were not given adequate land.

i. “In terms of square miles, the Joseph tribes had little reason to complain. Moreover, the land they were given was the most fertile in all Palestine. Joshua was certainly justified in resisting their request.” (Madvig)

ii. “They complained, ‘We haven’t enough room!’ The fact was that the enemy was deeply entrenched in the area which they did have.” (Redpath)

iii. “The Joseph tribes exhibited a degree of arrogance and greed in their confrontation with Joshua. The tone here sharply contrasts with the far more humble requests presented by Caleb (Joshua 14:6–12) and the daughters of Zelophehad (Joshua 17:4), both of whom appealed to the Lord’s promises as the basis for their requests.” (Howard)

iv. Only one lot: “They challenged the outcome of the lot (goral), which was controlled by God. Thus, in their request they were challenging the very workings of God himself.” (Howard)

v. “An all-wise God disposes his people according to his sovereign will. Let us not seek to alter our destiny, but let us try to make the best of our circumstances. This is what Joshua exhorted Ephraim and Manasseh to do.” (Spurgeon)

b. If you are a great people: Joshua’s reply was both wise and wonderful. He told them, “If you are a great people, then go and take the land for yourself; fully occupy what the LORD has given you.” These tribes had not completely taken the mountain country in their allotted territory, because it would be difficult and dangerous work.

i. “Joshua would not reverse the decision of the lot; but as there was much woodland country, he gave them permission to clear away as much of it as they found necessary to extend themselves as far as they pleased.” (Clarke)

ii. “If you say you are so great, if you think you are so wonderful, then there is plenty of unoccupied land within the limits of your present lot.” (Redpath)

c. The mountain country is not enough for us: The tribes of Joseph objected to Joshua’s proposal. They complained that the wooded areas that could be cleared were not enough. They complained that the enemies on the plains were too strong with their chariots of iron. They felt there were good reasons or excuses why they would not possess what God granted them.

i. “The hill is not enough for us, and the Canaanites are too hard for us.” (Trapp)

ii. The tribes of Joseph were afraid of the Canaanite chariots of iron. “Iron chariots, understood as chariots reinforced with some iron fittings, are envisaged.” (Hess)

iii. This was a different attitude compared to Caleb in Joshua 14:11-12. The men of Manasseh and Ephraim wanted a gift of “easy land.” They didn’t want to trust God’s promises and take what God had given them. The principle applies to believers today. Before expecting more from God, fully live in what He has already granted

iv. “Stop crying for greater opportunities until you have done the work in the place that God has allotted to you.” (Redpath)

d. Although it is wooded, you shall cut it down: Joshua’s reply to their objection was simple. “The work will be difficult, but you are a great people and have great power. As God is with you, you can overcome these challenges and fully live in what God has granted you.”

i. God had a purpose in allowing these difficult challenges to the tribes of Joseph, even as He has a purpose in allowing such challenges to believers today. “Difficulty is sent to reveal to us what God can do in answer to the faith that prays and works.” (Meyer)

Report a correction

Select text to highlight it · bookmark a section to find it again in your study.

These are trusted human voices, not Scripture itself. Weigh what they say against the Word.