Old Testament2 Samuel 3:33Historical Books

“Died Abner as a fool dieth?”

The full verse · 2 Samuel 3:33 · KJV

And the over , and , as a ?

Asked by

David

Asked to

Audience

The mourners at Abner's grave in Hebron, where "all the people wept" (2 Samuel 3:32)

The Scene

Joab has murdered Abner in the gate of Hebron (2 Samuel 3:27), and at Abner's burial David weeps aloud at the grave and laments over him (2 Samuel 3:31-33).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

David was mourning a man killed by treachery, and he wanted everyone to know Abner had not deserved it. The question expects the answer no. Gill says the meaning is that Abner did not die for any crime proved against him, but "was murdered in a clandestine, insidious, and deceitful manner." Matthew Henry hears it two ways: as grief that so great a man was "fooled out of his life" by a show of friendship, or as a declaration that Abner did not die as a criminal does. Keil & Delitzsch translate the line as an exclamation rather than a question, "Like an ungodly man must Abner die!", a lament that he died a death he did not deserve. The lament also showed David's own heart: Keil & Delitzsch say it gave "a still stronger proof of his innocence, and of the sincerity of his grief."

The Response

What Scripture records

David answered his own question in the next line: "Thy hands were not bound, nor thy feet put into fetters: as a man falleth before wicked men, so fellest thou" (2 Samuel 3:34). Abner had not been bound and executed as a criminal; as Keil & Delitzsch put it, "thou hast been treacherously murdered." "And all the people wept again over him" (2 Samuel 3:34). David refused to eat until the sun went down (2 Samuel 3:35), and "all the people and all Israel understood that day that it was not of the king to slay Abner the son of Ner" (2 Samuel 3:37).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

This is David's second lament in the book. He had mourned Saul and Jonathan (2 Samuel 1:17-27); now he mourns Abner, who had fought against him. Matthew Henry writes that "all former quarrels are forgotten and David is a true mourner for his fall."

The lament also names the wrong for what it was. By saying Abner fell "as a man falleth before wicked men" (2 Samuel 3:34), David spoke against the murder before all the people, with Joab among the mourners (2 Samuel 3:31). Gill remarks that Joab "must be an hardened creature" to stand at the grave and hear it without being moved. Years later Solomon said of Joab, "the LORD shall return his blood upon his own head, who fell upon two men more righteous and better than he," naming Abner first (1 Kings 2:32).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, when someone I have been at odds with is wronged or dies, how can I grieve honestly and speak truthfully about what happened?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. David wept for a man who had once been his enemy. What makes it hard to grieve for someone you have been at odds with?
  2. David's lament said plainly that Abner had been wronged. When have you seen someone speak honestly about a wrong at a painful moment, and what did it mean to those listening?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning