Old Testament1 Samuel 1:8Historical Books

“Hannah, why weepest thou? And why eatest thou not? And why is thy heart grieved? Am not I better to thee than ten sons?”

The full verse · 1 Samuel 1:8 · KJV

Then her to her, , why thou? and why thou not? and why is thy ? am not I to thee than ?

Asked by

Elkanah

Asked to

Hannah

The Scene

At the family's yearly sacrifice at Shiloh, Peninnah "provoked her; therefore she wept, and did not eat" (1 Samuel 1:7).

Journal Share image

Why It Was Asked

The purpose behind the question

Elkanah saw his wife weeping at a sacrificial feast and refusing to eat, and he wanted to reach her. His first three questions ask what lay behind her tears, her fasting, and her grieved heart. Gill notes that it was a feast, "a time of rejoicing," and that Elkanah had given her the best portion. His last question appeals to his love: "am not I better to thee than ten sons?" Keil & Delitzsch say he "sought to comfort her in her grief by the affectionate appeal." Matthew Henry sees more in it: "He gives her a loving reproof for it," urging her to consider whether her grief had gone too far.

The Response

What Scripture records

No answer from Hannah is recorded. Instead, "Hannah rose up after they had eaten in Shiloh, and after they had drunk," and "in bitterness of soul" she "prayed unto the LORD, and wept sore" (1 Samuel 1:9-10). She vowed that if the LORD would give her "a man child," she would give him to the LORD "all the days of his life" (1 Samuel 1:11). After Eli's blessing, "her countenance was no more sad" (1 Samuel 1:18), and in time "the LORD remembered her" and she bore Samuel (1 Samuel 1:19-20).

The Bigger Picture

Where this fits in God's story

Elkanah's love was real, and the text says so plainly: "he loved Hannah" (1 Samuel 1:5). But the same verse gives the reason for her grief: "the LORD had shut up her womb." Her husband could give her a worthy portion and his whole heart, but he could not give her what only the LORD could give. Matthew Henry suggests that Elkanah's question "perhaps occasioned her to think within herself, 'Whether he be so or no, God is, and therefore to him will I apply.'"

Whatever moved her, Hannah's next step was prayer. She brought her sorrow to the "LORD of hosts" (1 Samuel 1:11), and the story turns on the LORD's answer: "the LORD remembered her" (1 Samuel 1:19). Her later song celebrates the God who reverses such sorrow: "the barren hath born seven" (1 Samuel 2:5). The LORD went on to give her "three sons and two daughters" besides Samuel (1 Samuel 2:21).

The Commentaries

Voices from across the centuries

Generations of believers have studied this verse. See what they noticed.

Look Closer

Loading the questions…

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God

Lord, what sorrow am I carrying that even the people who love me cannot reach, and how do You want me to bring it to You?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others

  1. Elkanah's questions came from love, but they did not end Hannah's grief. When someone you love is hurting, what helps more than reasons?
  2. Tell about a time someone's comfort reached you, or missed you. What made the difference?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources

Keep questioning