“On the east side, toward the rising of the sun, those of the standard of the forces with Judah shall camp according to their armies; and Nahshon the son of Amminadab shall be the leader of the children of Judah.” And his army was numbered at seventy-four thousand six hundred. “Those who camp next to him shall be the tribe of Issachar, and Nethanel the son of Zuar shall be the leader of the children of Issachar.” And his army was numbered at fifty-four thousand four hundred. Then comes the tribe of Zebulun, and Eliab the son of Helon shall be the leader of the children of Zebulun.” And his army was numbered at fifty-seven thousand four hundred. All who were numbered according to their armies of the forces with Judah, one hundred and eighty-six thousand four hundred—these shall break camp first.”
a. On the east side, toward the rising of the sun: In the arrangement of the tribes, God started with the east side. In our western world, we normally orient things toward the north. In the ancient Near East, things were arranged toward the east, toward the rising of the sun.
i. “The placement on the east is very significant in Israel’s thought. East is the place of the rising of the sun, the source of hope and sustenance. Westward was the sea. Israel’s traditional stance was with its back to the ocean and the descent of the sun.” (Allen)
ii. “The front is eastward, and Judah has the post of honour in the van.” (Watson)
iii. “Judah encamped foremost. It was fit the lion should lead the way…. This order in their march showed the principality that should continue in this tribe till Shiloh came. Judah herein also was a type of Christ, who is ‘the Captain of the Lord’s host,’ (Joshua 5:14) and ‘of our salvation,’ (Hebrews 2:10) and goeth before his heavenly armies.” (Trapp)
b. On the east side, toward the rising of the sun, those of the standard of the forces with Judah shall camp according to their armies: Judah was first, and closest to the tabernacle itself. The tribes of Issachar and Zebulun followed in order after Judah. These tribes would order themselves after the standard (the banner or flag) of Judah, which is sometimes considered to bear the image of a lion.
i. Different sources cite different emblems or figures on these standards. Keil and Delitzsch admit “Neither the Mosaic law, nor the Old Testament generally, gives us any intimation as to the form or character of the standard,” and claim that rabbinical tradition describes the images on each standard. “According to rabbinical tradition, the standard of Judah bore the figure of a lion, that of Reuben the likeness of a man or of a man’s head, that of Ephraim the figure of an ox, and that of Dan the figure of an eagle.” However, they give no reference to any ancient rabbi, citing only the 16th-century Roman Catholic commentator Jerome de Prado.
ii. Adam Clarke, quoting Johann Jacob Scheuchzer (a Swiss physician and Bible commentator, 1672-1733), says that the “Talmudists” claim the four figures of a lion, a man, a calf, and an eagle for the standards of the four groups of tribes – but Clarke provides no citation.
iii. Louis Ginzberg in his Legends of the Jews gives a list without citation: “Judah’s standard bore in its upper part the figure of a lion, for its forefather had been characterized by Jacob as ‘a lion’s whelp’…. Reuben’s standard had in its upper part the figure of a man, corresponding to the mandrakes that Reuben, forefather of this tribe, found, for this plant had the form of a manikin…. In the standard of Ephraim was fashioned the form of a fish, for Jacob had blessed the forefather of this tribe by telling him to multiply like a fish…. Dan’s standard contained the form of a serpent, for ‘Dan shall be a serpent by the way,’ was Jacob’s blessing for this tribe.” Ginzberg also gives a second list (without citation) of a figure or image representing each tribe.
iv. The 1675 Portuguese book Thesouro de Nobreza (Thesaurus of Nobility) gives the coats of arms of many noble families both of its time and from history. The first chapter of the book is titled “Weapons of the Tribes of Israel” and it presents an imagined coat of arms for each of the twelve tribes of Israel. Later in the book it pictures imagined coats of arms for Joshua, David, Alexander the Great, Julius Caesar, King Arthur, and many others.
v. “Jewish tradition suggests that the tribal banners corresponded in color to the twelve stones in the breastpiece of the high priest (Exodus 28:15-21). Further, this tradition holds that the standard of the triad led by Judah had the figure of a lion, that of Reuben the figure of a man, that of Ephraim the figure of an ox, and that of Dan the figure of an eagle (see the four living creatures described by Ezekiel 1:10; cf. Revelation 4:7). These traditions are late, however, and difficult to substantiate historically, as the Torah does not describe the nature or designs of the banners of Numbers 2.” (Allen)
vi. With no reference or citation, Morgan wrote: “On the east – that is, fronting the entrance – the standard-bearing tribe was Judah, with its symbol of a lion of gold on a field of scarlet…. On the west, Ephraim’s standard was a black ox on a field of gold…. On the south, Reuben bore the standard on which was a man on a field of gold…. On the north, Dan was the standard-bearing tribe, his symbol being an eagle of gold on a field of blue.”
vii. In summary, we don’t have firm biblical evidence for what appeared on the standard (the banner or flag) of Judah or any of the other tribes, though many figures have been suggested.
Tribe Keil Clarke Th. of Nobility Ginzberg 1 Ginzberg 2
Reuben Man River/Man Mandrakes Man Mandrakes
Simeon Sword City City
Judah Lion Lion Lion Lion Lion
Issachar Donkey Sun/Moon/Donkey Sun & Moon
Zebulun Ship Ship Ship
Dan Eagle Serpent/Eagle Serpent Serpent Serpent
Naphtali Stag Stag Stag
Gad Lion Soldiers
Asher Grain Olive Tree Olive Tree
Ephraim Calf Unicorn Bull Fish Bull
Manasseh Bull Unicorn Unicorn
Benjamin Wolf Wolf Wolf
c. And Nahshon the son of Amminadab shall be the leader of the children of Judah: God recognized a specifically called leader (Nahshon) for the tribe of Judah, and for each of the tribes following. The order and organization God called Israel to embrace required leadership, with leaders both recognized by God and respected by the people.
i. “Without this pattern, apart from this order, the Hebrews would have remained a mob—large, disorganized, unruly, and bound for disaster. With this pattern, and the discipline and devotion it implied, was the opportunity for grand victory.” (Allen)
d. One hundred and eighty-six thousand four hundred: The total number of available soldiers among the eastward tribes was 186,400.
e. These shall break camp first: There was an order to the encampment and for the marching of the tribes. They were to move as an orderly army, not as a random mob.
i. “This whole chapter is very full of interest as revealing the orderliness of the Divine arrangements. This host of God was not a mob, lacking order. It was a disciplined company.” (Morgan)