A. Two laws to protect criminals and animals.
1. (1-3) A limit on corporal punishment.
“If there is a dispute between men, and they come to court, that the judges may judge them, and they justify the righteous and condemn the wicked, then it shall be, if the wicked man deserves to be beaten, that the judge will cause him to lie down and be beaten in his presence, according to his guilt, with a certain number of blows. Forty blows he may give him and no more, lest he should exceed this and beat him with many blows above these, and your brother be humiliated in your sight.
a. If there is a dispute between men, and they come to court: By the direction of God, Israel’s legal system made the distinction between criminal cases (where rulers punished crime through judges) and civil cases (where the people brought disputes before judges). This was a way to resolve disputes apart from violence.
b. They justify the righteous and condemn the guilty: Regarding both criminal and civil cases, the duty of Israel’s judges was simple. They were to approve and encourage the righteous and condemn those who were guilty. When the righteous are penalized and the guilty are rewarded, courts of justice are not fulfilling their God-given responsibility (Romans 13:4).
c. If the wicked man deserves to be beaten: The context is of a civil case, a dispute between men. Those who were found to be wicked in their treatment of others, even in disputes between men, received physical punishment (or presumably, the equivalent). This would discourage those who were in the wrong from bringing the case before judges, and encourage disputes to be settled without bringing the matter before judges.
i. The law did not require 40 lashes; the punishment of the guilty man would be according to his guilt, and not more. However, the total number of strokes could not exceed 40.
ii. “Among the Mohammedans there are very few law-suits, and the reason is given…because they that sue others without just cause are to be whipped publicly.” (Trapp)
d. Forty blows may he give him and no more: Though sometimes a beating was the appropriate punishment, God’s law also recognized that punishment could be excessive, and therefore gave limits to penalties. The penalty was to be given in the presence of the judge, so he could make sure the punishment was not excessive.
i. In 2 Corinthians 11:24, Paul listed this among his apostolic credentials: From the Jews five times I received forty stripes minus one. The forty stripes minus one means Paul was beaten by the Jewish authorities with thirty-nine blows on five different occasions. One was subtracted both out of caution of a miscount, and as a small expression of mercy.
e. Lest…your brother be humiliated in your sight: God commanded that the dignity of even the guilty man be respected. To flog a man more than his wrong deserved would be to treat him more like an animal than a man.
i. “His sinful conduct against a brother was not sufficient cause to rob him of his full dignity.” (Merrill)
ii. “It is interesting to notice what excessive punishment is to the mind of God. It is anything which makes our brother appear vile in our sight.” (Morgan)