“What be these?”
The full verse · Zechariah 1:19 · KJV
And I unto the that with me, What be these? And he me, These are the which have , , and .
Asked by
Asked to
The angel who talked with Zechariah, serving as divine interpreter of the night visions.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionZechariah asks to understand the symbolic meaning of the horns in his vision. By framing his confusion as a question rather than waiting passively, he actively engages the angelic messenger and models humble inquiry into divine revelation.
The Response
What Scripture recordsThe angel answered that these horns were the powers that had scattered Judah, Israel, and Jerusalem, identifying them as instruments of divine judgment against God’s covenant people.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyZechariah’s question reveals both his bewilderment and his wisdom. The prophet sees four horns in his vision but lacks interpretive framework for these symbols. Rather than speculating or remaining silent, he directly asks the attending angel for explanation. The Hebrew construction מָה־אֵלֶּה (mah-elleh, what are these) is straightforward and humble, the language of a learner rather than a visionary claiming autonomous understanding. This questioning approach establishes the pattern for apocalyptic literature, where symbolic visions require divine interpretation. The angel’s response identifies the horns as hostile powers that scattered God’s people, likely representing Babylon, Assyria, Egypt, and other nations that decimated Israel and Judah. Zechariah asks because symbolic revelation demands explanation, and his question opens the door to understanding God’s justice and coming restoration.
When life feels chaotic and threatening forces seem to dominate, ask God for understanding. Zechariah didn’t pretend to comprehend the disturbing symbols before him. He asked, and received clarity that reframed his fear into hope, these hostile powers were already under God’s sovereign awareness and coming judgment. When you face circumstances that scatter your peace, family, or faith community, bring your confusion directly to God. He delights in interpreters, Scripture, mature believers, the Holy Spirit, who can show you that no force operates beyond his ultimate control. As Psalm 2:4 reminds us, the Lord laughs at raging nations, and his purposes will prevail.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“What come these to do?”
“O my lord, what are these?”
“What are these, my lord?”
“What are these two olive trees upon the right side of the candlestick and upon the left side thereof?”