“When he giveth quietness, who then can make trouble?”
The full verse · Job 34:29 · KJV
When he giveth , who then can make ? and when he his , who then can him? whether it be done against a , or against a :
Asked by
Asked to
Job directly, though Elihu also addresses Job’s three friends and asserts truth before God himself as witness.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionElihu argues from God’s absolute sovereignty that human attempts to judge or demand visibility from God are futile, thereby rebuking Job’s insistence on a divine hearing and defending God’s freedom to act or remain silent according to His own wisdom.
The Response
What Scripture recordsJob does not directly answer these questions. He remains silent through Elihu’s entire discourse spanning chapters 32-37, offering no rebuttal until God Himself speaks from the whirlwind in chapter 38.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyElihu poses two parallel questions asserting God’s sovereign immunity from human judgment and scrutiny. The first question challenges who can condemn when God grants shaqat, rest or quietness, whether understood as God’s own tranquility or the peace He bestows. The second addresses divine hiddenness, the samar panim or hiding of God’s face, a biblical idiom for withdrawn presence. By framing these as rhetorical questions rather than statements, Elihu forces his audience to acknowledge their own answer: no one. The interrogative form compels recognition of human limitation before divine sovereignty. Whether applied to nations or individuals, the principle holds: God operates beyond human capacity to judge or comprehend. This carries significant theological weight, defending God’s right to act or refrain from acting without human approval, while simultaneously preparing Job for God’s own questions that will soon follow from the whirlwind.
When God seems silent in your struggle, you aren’t qualified to put Him on trial. Elihu’s questions expose our impulse to demand God’s immediate presence or explanation during suffering. Yet Scripture reveals that God’s hiddenness often precedes His most powerful revelations, as Joseph discovered in prison and Israel learned in exile. Rather than interpreting silence as indifference, consider that God may be working beneath the surface of your awareness. ‘For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, declares the LORD’ (Isaiah 55:8). Trust doesn’t require constant visibility. Wait with patient faith, knowing that Christ Himself endured the Father’s hidden face so you would never be ultimately forsaken.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources