“Shall I not visit them for these things?”
The full verse · Jeremiah 9:9 · KJV
Shall I not them for these things? the : shall not my be on such a as this?
Asked by
Asked to
God addresses the nation of Judah through the prophet Jeremiah, with broader witness to surrounding nations observing God’s covenant faithfulness in judgment.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionGod uses rhetorical questions to force acknowledgment of His justice rather than merely declaring judgment. The interrogative form invites, even demands, agreement that His response is morally necessary. By framing inevitable punishment as a question, God appeals to the innate human sense of justice, making His actions self-evidently right.
The Response
What Scripture recordsNo verbal response is recorded. The rhetorical questions function as prophetic declaration, with implied affirmation that God will indeed execute judgment. The historical response comes through Babylon’s invasion and Jerusalem’s destruction in 586 BC, confirming God’s announced visitation.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyGod’s double rhetorical question intensifies the certainty of coming judgment on Judah’s systematic covenant violations. The Hebrew paqad carries nuanced meaning. God will ‘visit’ in the sense of carefully attending to their sins with appropriate response, not overlooking or forgetting. By asking rather than simply declaring, God appeals to the moral intuition He placed within humanity, forcing acknowledgment that justice requires response to evil. The parallelism between punishing ‘these things’ and avenging Himself on ‘such a nation’ emphasizes both the specific sins and the corporate guilt. God’s questions invite agreement that His character as righteous judge demands action when His covenant people persist in deceit, adultery, and injustice described in the surrounding verses. The interrogative form makes judgment feel inevitable rather than arbitrary, rooted in moral necessity rather than divine caprice.
When you feel God’s discipline, remember He asks these questions in grief, not glee. God’s rhetorical questions in Jeremiah reveal that judgment is never His delight but His moral necessity when rebellion persists. When facing consequences for sin, recognize that God’s discipline proves His covenant faithfulness, not His abandonment. The same God who must punish sin has provided Christ to bear that punishment, transforming visitation into salvation for all who trust Him. As Hebrews 12:6 reminds us, ‘the Lord disciplines the one he loves,’ turning even painful consequences into pathways back to His heart. Let God’s justice drive you to the cross, where punishment and mercy embrace.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“For how shall I do for the daughter of my people?”
“Who is the wise man, that may understand this?”
“Who would not fear thee, O King of nations?”
“Do they provoke me to anger?”