“Shall I not visit for these things?”
The full verse · Jeremiah 5:9 · KJV
Shall I not for these things? the : and shall not my be on such a as this?
Asked by
Asked to
The southern kingdom of Judah, addressed as representative of covenant unfaithfulness, with implications extending to all nations characterized by similar rebellion.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionGod uses rhetorical questioning to declare His personal investment in justice rather than detached judgment. The reflexive construction avenge myself emphasizes that covenant violation personally offends divine holiness, making the question both a declaration of intent and an appeal to acknowledge the reasonableness of His response to sustained betrayal.
The Response
What Scripture recordsThe text provides no recorded verbal response. The subsequent chapters show Judah’s continued refusal to return to God despite escalating warnings, leading to Babylonian invasion and exile.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyJeremiah’s double question ‘Shall I not punish them for these things? Shall I not avenge myself on a nation such as this?’ recurs with remarkable precision in Jeremiah 5:29 and 9:9, creating a refrain of judicial inevitability through the early chapters of the book. The Hebrew paqod (visit, punish) carries the sense of deliberate, attentive scrutiny that results in consequential action, God does not punish arbitrarily but as the natural outcome of covenant examination. By asking rather than declaring, Jeremiah makes the community answer for themselves: given what has just been catalogued, wholesale adultery, the swearing of false oaths, the houses full of deceit (5:7–8), can they claim that punishment would be unjust? The question form is simultaneously rhetorical verdict and last invitation to self-examination before the verdict becomes historical reality.
God takes personal offense at persistent covenant betrayal, not from wounded pride but from violated relationship. When we treat grace as license or assume our privileges exempt us from accountability, we misunderstand the personal nature of sin against a holy God. This question warns that privilege intensifies rather than diminishes responsibility. Yet even in announcing vengeance, God’s question invites acknowledgment of His justice, creating space for repentance before judgment falls. Hebrews 10:30-31 echoes this truth: vengeance belongs to the Lord, and it is fearful to fall into His hands, yet He still calls us to draw near with confidence through Christ’s blood.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources