“Who are those with thee?”
The full verse · Genesis 33:5 · KJV
And he lifted his , and the and the ; and , Who are with thee? And he , The which hath graciously thy .
Asked by
Asked to
Jacob, who is traveling with his wives, children, and servants as he returns to Canaan after his years in Paddan-aram.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionEsau asks to understand the identity and relationship of the women and children accompanying Jacob, demonstrating genuine interest in his brother’s life after their long estrangement. The question invites Jacob to introduce his family and serves as a relational bridge in their reconciliation.
The Response
What Scripture recordsJacob replied, ‘The children whom God has graciously given your servant’ (Genesis 33:5), attributing his family directly to God’s grace rather than his own effort or merit.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyEsau’s question reveals genuine curiosity about the large group traveling with Jacob, eleven children visible at this point, plus their mothers and servants. The Hebrew construction (mi-elleh lak) is straightforward, asking about identity and belonging. Esau asks using a question rather than making assumptions, showing respect for Jacob’s autonomy and creating space for Jacob to share on his own terms. This contrasts with their last interaction, which was marked by deception and threat. The question’s simplicity carries emotional weight: these brothers haven’t seen each other in two decades, and Esau knows nothing of Jacob’s life in Haran. Theologically, Esau’s inquiry creates the opportunity for Jacob’s confession of God’s grace, turning a family introduction into a testimony. The question marks a pivotal moment where estranged brothers begin rebuilding relationship through honest, open dialogue.
Every blessing we possess comes from God’s hand, not our striving. When someone asks about your family, your work, your life, do you point to God’s grace or your achievements? Jacob had spent years manipulating and scheming, yet he correctly identifies God as the source of his children. This models humility in testimony. Romans 11:36 reminds us that all things are ‘from him and through him and to him.’ Your relationships, your opportunities, even your challenges are opportunities to acknowledge God’s gracious work. This doesn’t mean false humility or denying your efforts, but recognizing the ultimate source. When you frame your life’s blessings as gifts rather than trophies, you invite others into wonder at God rather than envy of you.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“What meanest thou by all this drove which I met?”
“And what profit shall this birthright do to me?”
“What is thy name?”
“When Esau my brother meeteth thee, and asketh thee, saying, Whose art thou?”