“What is this that thou hast done unto me?”
The full verse · Genesis 12:18 · KJV
And , and , What is this that thou hast unto me? why didst thou not me that she was thy ?
Asked by
Asked to
Abram, the patriarch who introduced Sarai as his sister while concealing her status as his wife, now required to account for the omission.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionPharaoh demands explanation for Abram’s deliberate omission, pressing for the reasoning behind a choice that endangered Pharaoh’s household and violated the trust implicit in their arrangement.
The Response
What Scripture recordsScripture records no verbal response from Abram to either of Pharaoh’s questions. Following this confrontation, Pharaoh orders Abram’s departure with Sarai and all his possessions, commanding his men to escort them from Egypt (Genesis 12:19-20).
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyThis second question penetrates to Abram’s deliberate choice, using ‘lamah lo’ (why not) to demand justification for withholding essential information. The verb ‘higgadta’ (you told) from the root ‘nagad’ means to declare openly or make conspicuous, emphasizing that Abram chose strategic silence rather than innocent oversight. Pharaoh recognizes that full disclosure would have prevented the entire crisis; he would never have taken a married woman into his household, risking both divine judgment and moral guilt. The question format conveys Pharaoh’s rights as the wronged party to understand the reasoning behind Abram’s calculated deception. Theologically, this interrogation reverses expected roles: the pagan ruler demonstrates moral clarity while God’s chosen patriarch stands convicted of deception. It reveals that God’s covenant with Abram does not exempt him from accountability to universal standards of truth.
Half-truths create consequences you cannot control, but full honesty invites protection you cannot manufacture. Abram’s selective disclosure made Pharaoh an unwitting participant in potential adultery, proving that what we hide often harms others more than ourselves. When fear drives your narrative, ask yourself: Who am I endangering by managing the truth? Pharaoh deserved facts that would have changed his actions entirely, just as people around you deserve transparency that protects them from becoming entangled in your self-preservation schemes. Ephesians 4:25 instructs believers to put away falsehood and speak truth with neighbors because we are members of one another. Your silence about crucial facts can make others guilty by association, but your honest declaration, even when it costs you advantage, honors both God and neighbor. When truth-telling feels dangerous, remember that God protects His purposes without requiring your deceptive assistance.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“Why saidst thou, She is my sister?”
“What hast thou done unto us?”
“Did Sarah laugh, saying, Shall I of a surety bear a child, which am old?”
“What hast thou done?”