“Is this that thou hast brought us up out of Egypt, to kill us and our children and our cattle with thirst?”
The full verse · Exodus 17:3 · KJV
And the for ; and the against , and , Wherefore is this that thou hast us up out of , to us and our and our with ?
Asked by
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionThe people lodge a formal accusation against Moses by framing their complaint as a question, implying that his leadership has been either incompetent or malicious. By asking rather than stating, they create space for Moses to defend himself while simultaneously expressing their desperation and assigning blame for their suffering.
The Response
What Scripture recordsMoses cried out to the Lord in distress, asking what he should do with the people who were ready to stone him (Exodus 17:4). God instructed Moses to strike the rock at Horeb with his staff, promising that water would flow from it. Moses obeyed, striking the rock in the sight of the elders, and water gushed out for the people to drink.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyThis accusatory question reveals the Israelites’ spiritual regression from worship to rebellion in just weeks. The people frame their complaint with the Hebrew interrogative lamah, meaning ‘why’ or ‘for what purpose,’ which demands Moses justify his leadership. Their question assumes malicious intent, suggesting Moses purposefully brought them to die rather than acknowledging the possibility of divine testing or provision. They ask rather than declare because they still recognize Moses as God’s representative, yet their tone drips with sarcasm and hostility. The question’s rhetorical structure, linking Moses’ leadership directly to their deaths, attempts to force him into an impossible defense. Theologically, this moment exposes humanity’s tendency to reinterpret God’s deliverance as cruelty the moment circumstances become difficult, revealing how quickly gratitude dissolves into accusation when faith is not anchored in God’s character.
When crisis exposes your fear, do you question God’s goodness or seek His provision? The Israelites confused temporary hardship with divine abandonment, forgetting that the same God who delivered them from Egypt could sustain them in the wilderness. When circumstances threaten your security, financial pressures, health concerns, relational breakdowns, resist the temptation to accuse God of malicious intent. Instead, follow Moses’ example: bring your honest desperation to God while trusting His character. Psalm 78:15-16 reminds us that God ‘split rocks in the wilderness and gave them drink abundantly as from the deep.’ Your current thirst does not mean God has forgotten you; it may be the prelude to a miracle that reveals His faithfulness in ways you never imagined.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources